Problems of legal policy implementation in the field of internationalization of higher legal education
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2019.104Abstract
The Bologna process, globalization, national boundary-spanning necessitate the internationalization of higher legal education. However, the existing Federal educational standards (SES) for bachelor, specialist and master law programs are focused on training lawyers for the domestic legal system, as well as the training of lawyers in foreign countries is mainly aimed at the national legal system, which complicates the mutual recognition of diplomas, academic mobility and employment of our graduates in other countries. The national legal policy in the internationalization of higher legal education is not consistent either, and it has not brought the expected results. Therefore, it is necessary to determine possible solutions. Materials and methods. The empirical grounds of the research are the researchers’ experience in teaching law, including master’s programs aimed at the formation of competencies in international law. Formal-legal, comparative-legal and dialectical methods were used in the research to analyze the current educational legislation and the practice of its implementation. Results of the research. The gaps in the implementation of the policy of internationalization of higher legal education are identified. It is proved that the competences formulated SES are mainly focused on training lawyers for the Russian legal system. The absence of SES focused on training lawyers with universal competences does not allow to fully implement integrative programs.
Keywords:
comparative jurisprudence, legal education, lawyer, integration of legal education, master course, bachelor course, Bologna agreements, educational standards
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Библиография
Беспалов, Михаил В., Котенев, Владимир А., Кузьмин, Антон В., Ряховская, Татьяна В. 2014. «Государственная политика и правовое регулирование в сфере образования и системе образовательных услуг в современной России». Вестник Тамбовского государственного университета 12: 132–140.
Боброва, Наталья А. 2018. «Первый Российский профессорский форум». Правоприменение 1: 180–184.
Бондарь, Николай С. 2013. «Современные ориентиры российского юридического образования: национальные традиции или космополитические иллюзии?». Юридическое образование и наука 1: 7–16.
Вавилова, Анна А., Ладнушкина, Нина М., Питько, Елена В. 2016. Образовательное право. М.: Книгодел.
Галиев, Фарит Х., Раянов Фанис. 2018. «Когда рецензию писать не только приятно, но и почетно. О книге “Философия. Философия права. Юридическая наука”». Правовое государство: теория и практика: 206–209.
Козюк, Михаил Н. 2016. «Юридическое образование в поисках юридической науки». Юридическое образование и наука 3: 32–38.
Малешин, Дмитрий Я. 2018. «Сравнительный гражданский процесс: опыт преподавания в Московском и Санкт-Петербургском университетах». Вестник Санкт-Петербургского университета. Право 2: 242–252.
Малько, Александр В., Саломатин, Алексей Ю. 2011. «Сравнительное правоведение в российском юридическом образовании». Государство и право 2: 39–45.
Малько, Александр В., Трофимов, Василий В. 2013. «Правовая политика в современной России: проблемы доктринального понимания и формирования». Государство и право 2: 5–13.
Марченко, Николай М. 2007. «Правовая политика современной России и региональное правотворчество». Образование и общество 1: 70–91.
Мережко, Александр. 2001. «Юридическое образование в США и на Украине». Юридическая практика 2: 20–21.
Поленина, Светлана В. 2011. «Правовая политика — генерализующий фактор правотворчества». Государство и право 1: 94–96.
Поляков, Андрей В. 2003. Общая теория права. Курс лекций. СПб.: Изд-во Санкт-Петербургского университета.
Провалинский, Дмитрий И. 2015. «Роль правовых стимулов в инновационной политике российского государства». Вестник Саратовской государственной юридической академии 2: 94–99.
Пронин, Александр А. 2018. «Нормативно-правовые аспекты государственной политики в сфере качества российского образования». Известия высших учебных заведений. Уральский регион 1: 14–21.
Протасов, Валерий Н. 2017. «Иррациональные методы властвования как инструмент самосохранения и экспансии бюрократических организованных систем управления». Государство и право 10: 55–61.
Пузиков, Руслан В. 2009. «Правовая политика России в сфере образования». Право и образование 4: 35–40.
Рожков, Александр И. 2016. Образовательное право. М.: Юрайт.
Рудковский, Виктор А. 2009. Правовая политика и осуществление права. Волгоград: Изд-во Волгоградского университета.
Саломатин, Алексей Ю. 2009. «Сравнительное правоведение в контексте современного юридического образования». Известия вузов. Правоведение 5: 134–143.
Самигуллин, Венир К. 2010. «Правовая политика как разновидность политики». Правовое государство: теория и практика 4: 10–14.
Семенова, Наталия С. 2015. «Правовые основы политики Европейского Союза в сфере образования». Право и образование 6: 26–27.
Смирнов, Дмитрий А. 2017. «О некоторых аспектах правового регулирования в системе высшего профессионального образования (на примере Российской Федерации и Абхазии)». Правовая политика в социально-экономической сфере в России и зарубежных странах. Сборник научных трудов. Ставрополь: 56–59.
Шпаковская, Людмила Л. 2007. Политика высшего образования в Европе и России. СПб.: Норма.
Dubin, Peter A. 2000. “Clinical Education for This Millennium: The Third Wave”. Clinical. Rev. 1: 13–26.
Friedman, Lawrens M. 1985. A History of American Law. New York.
Hochstettler, Tohmas J. 2004. “Aspiring to Steeples of Excellence at German Universities”. Chronicle of Higher Education 50: 47–50.
Malko, Alexander V. 2014. Theory of legal policy: current issues. Saratov: Saratov State Law Academy Publishers.
Rekosh, Edwin. 2005. The Development of Legal Clinic Teaching: A Global Perspective in The Legal Clinics: The Idea, Organization, Methodology. Warsaw: The Legal Clinics Foundation.
Romermann, Volker, Paulus, Cristofer. 2003. Slussellqalifikationen fur Jurastudium, Examen und Beruf. Munchen: C. H. Beck.
Stimpson, Bill. 2000. World of Change. London.
Underhill, James. 2003. Humboldt, Worldview and Language. Oxford University Press.
Zakhartsev, Sergei I., Salnikov, Viktor P. 2018. The philosophy of law and legal science. Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
References
Bespalov, Mikhail V., Kotenev, Vladimir A., Kuz'min, Anton V., Riakhovskaia, Tat'iana V. 2014. “Gosudarstvennaia politika i pravovoe regulirovanie v sfere obrazovaniia i sisteme obrazovatel'nykh uslug v sovremennoi Rossii” [“State Policy and Legal Regulation in the Sphere of Education and Education Services in Modern Russia”]. Vestnik Tambovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Vestnik of Tambov State University] 12: 132–140. (In Russian)
Bobrova, Natal'ia A. 2018. “Pervyi Rossiiskii professorskii forum” [“First Russian Forum of Professors”]. Pravoprimenenie [Law Enforcement] 1: 180–184. (In Russian)
Bondar', Nikolai S. 2013. “Sovremennye orientiry rossiiskogo iuridicheskogo obrazovaniia: natsional'nye traditsii ili kosmopoliticheskie illiuzii?” [“Modern Reference Points of Russian Legal Education: National Traditions or Cosmopolitan Illusions?”]. Iuridicheskoe obrazovanie i nauka [Legal Education and Science] 1: 7–16. (In Russian)
Dubin, Peter A. 2000. “Clinical Education for This Millennium: The Third Wave”. Clinical. Rev. 1: 13–26.
Friedman, Lawrens M. 1985. A History of American Law. New York.
Galiev, Farit Kh., Raianov, Fanis. 2018. “‘Kogda retsenziiu pisat' ne tol'ko priiatno, no i pochetno.’ O knige ‘Filosofiia. Filosofiia prava. Iuridicheskaia nauka’ Zakhartsev Sergei I. i Vladimir P. Sal'nikov” [“‘When Writing a Review is not only Pleasant but is also an Honor’. Review on ‘The Philosophy of Law and Legal Science’ by Sergei. I. Zakhartsev and Vladimir. P. Sal’nikov”]. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teoriia i praktika [The Rule-of-Law State: Theory and Practice]: 206–209. (In Russian)
Hochstettler, Tohmas J. 2004. “Aspiring to Steeples of Excellence at German Universities”. Chronicle of Higher Education 50: 47–50.
Koziuk, Mikhail N. 2016. “Iuridicheskoe obrazovanie v poiskakh iuridicheskoi nauki” [“Legal Education in Search for Legal Science”]. Iuridicheskoe obrazovanie i nauka [Legal Education and Science] 3: 32–38.(In Russian)
Maleshin, Dmitrii Ia. 2018. “Sravnitel'nyi grazhdanskii protsess: opyt prepodavaniia v Moskovskom i Sankt-Peterburgskom universitetakh” [“Comparative Civil Procedure: Teaching Experience at Moscow State and Saint Petersburg State Universities”]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Pravo [Vestnik of Saint-Petersburg University. Law] 2: 242–252. (In Russian)
Mal'ko, Aleksandr V., Salomatin, Aleksei Iu. 2011. “Sravnitel'noe pravovedenie v rossiiskom iuridicheskom obrazovanii” [“Compartive Legal Science in Russian Legal Education”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 2: 39–45. (In Russian)
Mal'ko, Aleksandr V., Trofimov, Vasilii V. 2013. “Pravovaia politika v sovremennoi Rossii: problemy doktrinal'nogo ponimaniia i formirovaniia” [“Legal Policy in Modern Russia: Problems of Doctrine Understanding and Formation”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 2: 5–13. (In Russian)
Malko, Alexander V. 2014. Theory of Legal Policy: Current Issues. Saratov: Saratov State Law Academy Publ.
Marchenko, Nikolai M. 2007. “Pravovaia politika sovremennoi Rossii i regional'noe pravotvorchestvo” [“Legal Policy of Modern Russia and Regional Lawmaking”]. Obrazovanie i obshchestvo [Education and Society] 1: 70–91. (In Russian)
Merezhko, Aleksandr. 2001. “ Iuridicheskoe obrazovanie v SShA i na Ukraine” [“Legal Education in the USA and Ukraine”]. Iuridicheskaia praktika [Legal Practice] 2: 20–21. (In Russian)
Polenina, Svetlana V. 2011. “Pravovaia politika — generalizuiushchii faktor pravotvorchestva” [“Legal Policy — Generalizing Factor of Lawmaking”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 1: 94–96. (In Russian)
Poliakov, Andrei V. 2003. Obshchaia teoriia prava. Kurs. Lektsii [General Theory of Law. Course of Lectures]. St. Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta Publ. (In Russian)
Pronin, Aleksandr A. 2018. “Normativno-pravovye aspekty gosudarstvennoi politiki v sfere kachestva rossiiskogo obrazovaniia” [“Normative Legal Aspects of State Policy in the Sphere of Russian Education Quality”]. Izvestiia vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Ural'skii region [News of Higher Education Establishments. Ural Region] 1: 14–21. (In Russian)
Protasov, Valerii N. 2017. “Irratsional'nye metody vlastvovaniia kak instrument samosokhraneniia i ekspansii biurokraticheskikh organizovannykh sistem upravleniia” [“Irrational Methods of Governing as Instrument of Self-protection and Expansion of Bureaucratically Organized Systems of Management”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 10: 55–61. (In Russian)
Provalinskii, Dmitrii I. 2015. “Rol' pravovykh stimulov v innovatsionnoi politike rossiiskogo gosudarstva”[“Role of Legal Incentives in Innovation Policy of Russia”]. Vestnik Saratovskoi gosudarstvennoi iuridicheskoi akademii [Herald of Saratov State Legal Academy] 2: 94–99. (In Russian)
Puzikov, Ruslan V. 2009. “Pravovaia politika Rossii v sfere obrazovaniia” [“Legal Policy of Russia in the Sphere of Education”]. Pravo i obrazovanie [Law and Education] 4: 35–40. (In Russian)
Rekosh, Edwin. 2005. The Development of Legal Clinic Teaching: A Global Perspective in The Legal Clinics: The Idea, Organization, Methodology. Warsaw: The Legal Clinics Foundation.
Romermann, Volker, Paulus, Cristofer. 2003. Slussellqalifikationen fur Jurastudium, Examen und Beruf. Munchen: C. H. Beck.
Rozhkov, Aleksandr I. 2016. Obrazovatel'noe pravo [Education Law]. Moscow: Iurait Publ. (In Russian)
Rudkovskii, Viktor A. 2009. Pravovaia politika i osushchestvlenie prava [Legal Policy and Implementation of Law]. Volgograd: Izdatel'stvo Volgogradskogo universiteta Publ. (In Russian)
Salomatin, Aleksei Iu. 2009. “Sravnitel'noe pravovedenie v kontekste sovremennogo iuridicheskogo obrazovaniia”[“Compertive Legal Studies in the Context of Modern Legal Education”]. Izvestiia vuzov. Pravovedenie [Bulletin of Higher Education Establishments. Legal Studies] 5: 134–143. (In Russian)
Samigullin, Venir K. 2010. “Pravovaia politika kak raznovidnost' politiki” [“Legal Policy as Type of Policy”]. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teoriia i praktika [The Rule-of-Law State: Theory and Practice] 4: 10–14. (In Russian)
Semenova, Nataliia S. 2015. “Pravovye osnovy politiki Evropeiskogo Soiuza v sfere obrazovaniia” [“Legal Basis of European Union Policy in the Sphere of Education”]. Pravo i obrazovanie [Law and Education] 6: 26–27. (In Russian)
Smirnov, Dmitrii A. 2017. “O nekotorykh aspektakh pravovogo regulirovaniia v sisteme vysshego professional'nogo obrazovaniia (na primere Rossiiskoi Federatsii i Abkhazii)” [“On Several Aspects of Legal Regulation in the System of Higher Professional Education (by the example of the Russian Federation and Abkhazia)”] Pravovaia politika v sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoi sfere v Rossii i zarubezhnykh stranakh. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Legal Policy in Social-Economical Sphere in Russia and Foreign Countries. Collection of Research Papers]. Stavropol': 56–59. (In Russian)
Shpakovskaia, Liudmila L. 2007. Politika vysshego obrazovaniia v Evrope i Rossii. [Higher Education Policy in Europe and Russia]. St. Petersburg: Norma Publ. (In Russian)
Stimpson, Bill. 2000. World of Change. London.
Underhill, James. 2003. Humboldt, Worldview and Language. Oxford University Press.
Vavilova, Anna A., Ladnushkina, Nina M., Pit'ko, Elena V. 2016. Obrazovatel'noe pravo [Education Law]. Moscow: Knigodel Publ. (In Russan)
Zakhartsev, Sergei I, Salnikov, Viktor P. 2018. The philosophy of Law and Legal Science. Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Downloads
Published
2019-01-31
How to Cite
Малько, А. В., Липинский, Д. А., & Саломатин, А. Ю. (2019). Problems of legal policy implementation in the field of internationalization of higher legal education. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law, 10(1), 55–71. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2019.104
Issue
Section
Public and Private Law: Applied Research
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
