Соотношение права и закона в России как историко-правовая проблема

Ярослав Борисович Жолобов; Виктор Пантелеевич Очередько; Виктор Геннадьевич Бондарев; Александра Андреевна Дорская

doi:10.21638/spbu14.2019.102

Authors

Ярослав Борисович Жолобов Russian State University of Justice, North-West Branch, 5, Alexandrovsky Park, St. Petersburg, 197046, Russian Federation
Виктор Пантелеевич Очередько Russian State University of Justice, North-West Branch, 5, Alexandrovsky Park, St. Petersburg, 197046, Russian Federation
Виктор Геннадьевич Бондарев Russian State University of Justice, North-West Branch, 5, Alexandrovsky Park, St. Petersburg, 197046, Russian Federation
Александра Андреевна Дорская Herzen State Pedagogical University of Russia, 48, Moika, St. Petersburg, 191186, Russian Federation

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2019.102

Abstract

The article analysis a question about the ratio of law and lex in Russia in historical and legal researches in 19–20th centuries. The following issues are highlighted in the article: consideration of history of state and law or as a history of law; evolution of ratio of law and lex in Russia; chronological definition of the emergence of concepts “law” and “lex”; correctness of the use definition “law” and “lex” in the context of the centuries-old dualism of secular and ecclesiastical regulation of social relations. By analyzing university charters of The Russian Empire, it was revealed that the term “history of law” was used in Russian materials, but abroad the term “history of legislation” was used. The article shows the importance of tradition in studying historical and legal issues in soviet time, in spite of ideological attitudes. The possibilities of historical and legal science in the complex assessment of the concept of law are shown from the point of view of elements of formal legal sources of law, the use of a situational approach, which allows to consider options for equating law and lex and opposing them, considering law and lex as a substantive substance and legal form, identifying features of the Russian legal system in the context of the combinations “law-lawlessness”, “law-truth”. The article shows that in the 1990s in Russia, when the plan of legal reforms was in development the two approaches revealed : either legal reform was limited only to legislative reform, or was viewed as a process of changing legal awareness in the context of legal policy, legal ideology, “rooting” of new legal values, etc. The author's position is expressed that the last opinion is more preferable for Russian society.

Keywords:

law, lex, canon law, customary law, history of state and law, historical and legal science, University Charter

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография

Беляев, Иван Д. 1855. Как понимали давность в разное время и русское общество в своей жизни,и русские законы. М.: Б. и.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1856a. «Об общественном значении христианской церкви и ее учреждений на Руси от Владимира Святого до монгольского владычества». Журнал Министерства народного просвещения 7: 1–34.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1856b. Обзор исторического развития сельской общины в России. Сочинение Б. Чичерина. М.: Тип. А. Семена.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1858. О наследстве без завещания по древним русским законам до Уложения царя Алексея Михайловича. М.: Университетская типография.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1858–1859. История русского законодательства. М.: Б. и.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1860а. «О вызове в суд по древним русским законам до Уложения 1649 г.». Журнал министерства юстиции 3.2: 97–143.

Беляев, Иван Д. 1860b. Крестьяне на Руси. Исследование о постепенном изменении значения крестьян в русском обществе. М.: Университетская типография.

Владимирский-Буданов, Михаил Ф. 1875–1877. Конспект лекций по истории русского права. Киев: Типография Б. А. Жеромского. Вып. 1–2.

Владимирский-Буданов, Михаил Ф. 1882. Литература по истории русского права за 1880–1882 гг. Киев: Университетская типография.

Владимирский-Буданов, Михаил Ф. 1888. Важнейшие явления в литературе истории русского права за 1887 год. Рецензии. Киев: Университетская типография.

Всеобщая история государства и права. 1947. М.: Юрид. изд-во, Тип. «Красный пролетарий».

Ефремова, Надежда Н. 2016. «Историография Российского государства и права: краткий очерк». Государство и право 3: 23–27.

Лапаева, Валентина В. 2008. «Либертарная концепция права В. С. Нерсесянца (к 70-летию со дня рождения)». Государство и право 10: 69–77.

Лаптева, Людмила Е. 2013. «Закон и акт управления в пореформенной русской юриспруденции». Ученые записки: электронный научный журнал Курского государственного университета 1 (25): 131–135.

Рейц, Александр Магнус. 1836. Опыт истории российских государственных и гражданских законов. Пер. с нем. М.: Издательство Ф. Морошкина.

Ромашов, Роман А. б. д. Право — язык и масштаб свободы. Дата обращения 12 ноября, 2018. https://law.wikireading.ru/8988.

Ромашов, Роман А. 2007. Проблема соотношения понятий право и закон в контексте исторического и юридико-лингвистического анализа. Открытая лекция. Киев; Симферополь: Ин-т государства и права им. В. М. Корецкого НАН Украины, Изд-во «Логос».

Ромашов, Роман А. 2015. «Юридические формы и технологии законотворчества в условиях государственного абсолютизма (на примере России XVIII века)». Юридическая техника 9: 631–637.

Рощупкин, Алексей Ю. 2015. «Научное наследие историка И. Д. Беляева». История: факты и символы 4: 50–63.

С. В. Юшков: основоположник науки истории государства и права СССР: сб. трудов к 100-летию со дня рождения. Отв. ред. О. И. Чистяков. 1989. М.: Юридическая литература.

Сергеевич, Василий И. 2004. Лекции и исследования по древней истории русского права. М.: Зерцало.

Сидорова, Анна В. 2016. «Содержание термина “закон” в дохристианском праве Древней Руси». Наука XXI века: актуальные направления развития 1–2: 279–282.

Смирнов, Сергий К. 1855. История Московской Славяно-греко-латинской академии. М.: Типография В. Готье.

Тихомиров, Юрий А., Казимирчук, Владимир П., Медведев, Николай П. 1996. Драма российского закона. Отв. ред. В. П. Казимирчук. М.: Юридическая книга.

Томсинов, Владимир А. 2009. Юриспруденция Древней Руси и правовая культура Византии. Вестник Московского университета. Сер. 11. Право 4: 3–26.

Фархутдинов, Линар И. 2012. «Соотношение понятий права и закона в контексте языка философии». Ученые записки Казанского университета 154 (1): 214–219.

Феофилакт. 1706–1710. Scientia Sacra (Наука священная в богословских состязаниях, по учению святой Церкви восточной, Святого Писания, соборов и Отцов, умозрительно и с сопровождением противных мнений, изложенная в московской коллегии царя Петра Алексеевича. М.: Б. и.

Хбликян, Ерванд А. 2016. «Основные подходы к проблеме соотношения права и закона в российском законоведении первой половины XIX в. (на примере концепций законоведения Л. А. Цветаева и З. А. Горюшкина)». Право и государство: теория и практика 1 (133): 16–19.

Шаймарданова, Лилия Р. 2009. «Реализация представлений русского народа о законе и праве чрез образы судьи, царя и Бога». Lingua mobilis 3 (17): 115–126.

Эверс, Иоганн Филипп Густав. 1835. Древнейшее русское право в историческом его развитии. Пер. с нем. И. Платонова. СПб.: Типография Штаба Отдельного корпуса внутренней стражи.

Эверс, Иоганн Филипп Густав. 1840. Уставы и управление Новгорода в средние века. СПб.: Б. и.

Юшков, Серафим В. 1926a. Исследования по истории русского права. Вып. 1. Новоузенск: Тип. Комбината.

Юшков, Серафим В. 1926b. Судебник 1497 г. (к внешней истории памятника). Саратов: Правление Саратовского государственного университета.

Юшков, Серафим В. 1950. Русская Правда. Происхождение, источники, ее значение. М.: Гос. изд-во юрид. лит., Образцовая тип. Жданова.

Brand-Ballard, Jeffrey. 2010. Limits of Legality: The Ethics of Lawless Judging. Oxford University Press.

Campos, Andre Santos. 2014. “Aquinas's lex iniusta non est lex: A Test of Legal Validity”. Archiv fur Rechtsund Sozialphilosophie 100, 3: 366–378.

Friedland, Martin L. 1975. Access to the law а study conducted for the Law reform commission of Canada. Toronto: Carswell/Methuen.

Grabowski, Andrzej. 2013. Juristic Concept of the Validity of Statutory Law: A Critique of Contemporary Legal Nonpositivism. Berlin; Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.

Greenawalt, Kent R. 1987. Conflicts of Law and Morality. Oxford University Press.

Kretzmann, Norman. 1988. “Lex Iniusta Non Est Lex: Laws on Trial in Aquinas’s Court of Conscience”. American Journal of Jurisprudence 33: 99–121.

Russell, John S. 2000. “Trial by slogan: Natural law and lex iniusta non est lex”. Law and Philosophy 19 (4): 433–449.

Walker, David M. 1980. The Oxford Companion to Law. Oxford University Press.

References

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1855. Kak ponimali davnost' v raznoe vremia i russkoe obshchestvo v svoei zhizni, i russkie zakony [How the prescription at different times penetrated both Russian society in its life and Russian laws]. Moscow. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1856a. Obzor istoricheskogo razvitiia sel'skoi obshchiny v Rossii. Sochinenie B. Chicherina[Overview of the historical development of the rural community in Russia. The work of B. Chicherin]. Moscow: Tipografiia A. Semena Publ. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1856b. “Ob obshchestvennom znachenii khristianskoi tserkvi i ee uchrezhdenii na Rusi ot Vladimira Sviatogo do mongol'skogo vladychestva” [“On the social significance of the Christian church and its institutions in Russia from St. Vladimir to Mongol sovereignty”]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosveshcheniia [Journal of the Ministry of Education] 7: 1–34. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1858. O nasledstve bez zaveshchaniia po drevnim russkim zakonam do Ulozheniia tsaria Alekseia Mikhailovicha [On inheritance without a will under ancient Russian laws to the Code of the Tsar Alexei Mikhailovich]. Moscow: Universitetskaia tipografiia Publ. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1858–1859. Istoriia russkogo zakonodatel'stva [History of Russian legislation]. Moscow. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1860a. “O vyzove v sud po drevnim russkim zakonam do Ulozheniia 1649 g.” [“On the summons to the court of the ancient Russian laws before the Code of 1649”]. Zhurnal ministerstva iustitsii [Journal of the Ministry of Justice] 3.2: 97–143. (In Russian)

Beliaev, Ivan D. 1860b. Krest'iane na Rusi. Issledovanie o postepennom izmenenii znacheniia krest'ian v russkom obshchestve [Peasants in Russia. Study on the gradual change in the value of peasants in Russian society]. Moscow: Universitetskaia tipografiia Publ. (In Russian)

Brand-Ballard, Jeffrey. 2010. Limits of Legality: The Ethics of Lawless Judging. Oxford University Press.

Campos, Andre Santos. 2014. “Aquinas's lex iniusta non est lex: A Test of Legal Validity”. Archiv fur Rechtsund Sozialphilosophie 100 (3): 366–378.

Efremova, Nadezhda N. 2016. “Istoriografiia Rossiiskogo gosudarstva i prava: kratkii ocherk” [“Historiography of the Russian state and law: a brief essay”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 3: 23–27. (In Russian)

Evers, Iogann Filipp Gustav. 1835. Drevneishee russkoe pravo v istoricheskom ego razvitii [The most ancient Russian law in its historical development]. Transl. by I. Platonov. St. Petersburg: Tipografiia Shtaba Otdel'nogo korpusa vnutrennei strazhi Publ. (In Russian)

Evers, Iogann Filipp Gustav. 1840. Ustavy i upravlenie Novgoroda v srednie veka [Statutes and management of Novgorod in the Middle Ages]. St. Petersburg. (In Russian)

Farkhutdinov, Linar I. 2012. “Sootnoshenie poniatii prava i zakona v kontekste iazyka filosofii” [“Interrelation between the Concepts of Objective Law and Written Law in Terms of the Language of Philosophy”]. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta [Proceedings of Kazan University]. 154 (1): 214–219.(In Russian)

Feofilakt. 1706–1710. Scientia Sacra (Nauka sviashchennaia v bogoslovskikh sostiazaniiakh, po ucheniiu sviatoi Tserkvi vostochnoi, Sviatogo Pisaniia, soborov i Ottsov, umozritel'no i s soprovozhdeniem protivnykh mnenii, izlozhennaia v moskovskoi kollegii tsaria Petra Alekseevicha [Scientia Sacra (Science is sacred in theological competitions, according to the teachings of the holy Eastern Church, Holy Scriptures, cathedrals and Fathers, speculatively and accompanied by disgusting opinions, presented in the Moscow College of Tsar Peter Alekseevich]. Moscow. (In Russian)

Friedland, Martin L. 1975. Access to the law а study conducted for the Law reform commission of Canada. Toronto: Carswell/Methuen.

Grabowski, Andrzej. 2013. Juristic Concept of the Validity of Statutory Law: A Critique of Contemporary Legal Nonpositivism. Berlin; Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.

Greenawalt, Kent R. 1987. Conflicts of Law and Morality. Oxford University Press.

Iushkov, Serafim V. 1926a. Issledovaniia po istorii russkogo prava. Vyp. 1. [Studies on the history of Russian law. Issue 1]. Novouzensk: Tipografiia Kombinata Publ. (In Russian)

Iushkov, Serafim V. 1926b. Sudebnik 1497 g. (K vneshnei istorii pamiatnika) [Law code of 1497 (To the external history of the monument)]. Saratov: Pravlenie Saratovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta Publ. (In Russian)

Iushkov, Serafim V. 1950. Russkaia Pravda. Proiskhozhdenie, istochniki, ee znachenie [Russian Pravda. Origin, sources, its value]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo iuridicheskoi literatury, Obraztsovaia tipografiia Zhdanova Publ. (In Russian)

Khblikian, Ervand A. 2016. “Osnovnye podkhody k probleme sootnosheniia prava i zakona v rossiiskom zakonovedenii pervoi poloviny XIX v. (na primere kontseptsii zakonovedeniia L. A. Tsvetaeva i Z. A. Goriushkina)” [“The main approaches to the problem of the relationship between law and law in Russian jurisprudence of the first half of the XIX century (on the example of the concepts of jurisprudence L. A. Tsvetaev and Z. A. Goryushkin)”]. Pravo i gosudarstvo: teoriia i praktika [Law and the state: theory and practice] 1 (133): 16–19. (In Russian)

Kretzmann, Norman. 1988. “Lex Iniusta Non Est Lex: Laws on Trial in Aquinas's Court of Conscience”. American Journal of Jurisprudence 33: 99–121.

Lapaeva, Valentina V. 2008. “Libertarnaia kontseptsiia prava V. S. Nersesiantsa (k 70-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia)” [“The libertarian concept of the right of V. S. Nersesyants (on the 70th anniversary of his birth)”]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law] 10: 69–77. (In Russian)

Lapteva, Liudmila E. 2013. “Zakon i akt upravleniia v poreformennoi russkoi iurisprudentsii” [“The law and act of management in the post-reform Russian jurisprudence”]. Uchenye zapiski: elektronnyi nauchnyi zhurnal Kurskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Scientific Notes: The online academic journal of Kursk State University] 1 (25): 131–135. (In Russian)

Reits, Aleksandr Magnus. 1836. Opyt istorii rossiiskikh gosudarstvennykh i grazhdanskikh zakonov[Experience in the history of Russian state and civil laws]. Transl. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo F. Moroshkina Publ. (In Russian)

Romashov, Roman A. s. a. “Pravo — iazyk i masshtab svobody.” Accessed November 12, 2018. https://law.wikireading.ru/8988. (In Russian)

Romashov, Roman A. 2007. Problema sootnosheniia poniatii pravo i zakon v kontekste istoricheskogo i iuridiko-lingvisticheskogo analiza. Otkrytaia lektsiia. [The problem of the relationship between the notions of law and law in the context of historical and legal-linguistic analysis. Open lecture]. Kiev, Simferopol': Institut gosudarstva i prava im. V. M. Koretskogo NAN Ukrainy [Institute of State and Law n. a. V. M. Koretskogo the Ukrainian National Academy of Science], Logos Publ. (In Russian)

Romashov, Roman A. 2015. “Iuridicheskie formy i tekhnologii zakonotvorchestva v usloviiakh gosudarstvennogo absoliutizma (na primere Rossii XVIII veka)” [“Legal forms and technologies of lawmaking in conditions of state absolutism (on the example of Russia of the 18th century)”]. Iuridicheskaia tekhnika [Juridical Techniques] 9: 631–637. (In Russian)

Roshchupkin, Aleksei Iu. 2015. “Nauchnoe nasledie istorika I. D. Beliaeva” [“Historical heritage of the historian I. D. Belyaev”]. Istoriia: fakty i simvoly [History: facts and symbols] 4: 50–63. (In Russian)

Russell, John S. 2000. “Trial by slogan: Natural law and lex iniusta non est lex”. Law and Philosophy 19 (4): 433–449.

S. V. Iushkov: osnovopolozhnik nauki istorii gosudarstva i prava SSSR. Sbornik trudov k 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia. Otv. red. O. I. Chistiakov [S. V. Yushkov: founder of the history of science of the state and law of the USSR. Collection of works to the 100th anniversary of the birth. Ed. O. I. Chistyakov]. 1989. Moscow: Iuridicheskaia literatura Publ. (In Russian)

Sergeevich, Vasilii I. 2004. Lektsii i issledovaniia po drevnei istorii russkogo prava [Lectures and studies on the ancient history of Russian law]. Moscow: Zertsalo Publ. (In Russian)

Shaimardanova, Liliia R. 2009. “Realizatsiia predstavlenii russkogo naroda o zakone i prave chrez obrazy sud'i, tsaria i Boga” [“Realization of the ideas of the Russian people about law and law through the image of a judge, a tsar and God”]. Lingua mobilis 3 (17): 115–126. (In Russian)

Sidorova, Anna V. 2016. “Soderzhanie termina “zakon” v dokhristianskom prave Drevnei Rusi” [“The content of the term “law” in the pre-Christian law of Ancient Russia”]. Nauka XXI veka: aktual'nye napravleniia razvitiia [Science of the 21st century: current directions of development] 1–2: 279–282. (In Russian)

Smirnov, Sergii K. 1855. Istoriia Moskovskoi Slaviano-Greko-Latinskoi akademii [History of the Moscow Slavic-Greek-Latin Academy]. Moscow: Tipografiia V. Got'e Publ. (In Russian)

Tikhomirov, Iurii A., Vladimir P. Kazimirchuk, Nikolai P. Medvedev. 1996. Drama rossiiskogo zakona. Otv. red. V. P. Kazimirchuk [Drama of Russian Law. Ed. V. P. Kazimirchuk]. Moscow: Iuridicheskaia kniga Publ. (In Russian)

Tomsinov, Vladimir A. 2009. Iurisprudentsiia Drevnei Rusi i pravovaia kul'tura Vizantii [Jurisprudence of Ancient Russia and the legal culture of Byzantium]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 11. Pravo[Moscow State University Vestnik. Series 11. Law] 4: 3–26. (In Russian)

Vladimirskii-Budanov, Mikhail F. 1875–1877. Konspekt lektsii po istorii russkogo prava [Summary of lectures on the history of Russian law]. Kiev: Tipografiia B. A. Zheromskogo Publ. Iss. 1–2. (In Russian)

Vladimirskii-Budanov, Mikhail F. 1882. Literatura po istorii russkogo prava za 1880–1882 gg. [Literature on the history of Russian law in 1880–1882]. Kiev: Universitetskaia tipografiia Publ. (In Russian)

Vladimirskii-Budanov, Mikhail F. 1888. Vazhneishie iavleniia v literature istorii russkogo prava za 1887 god. Retsenzii [The most important phenomena in the literature of the history of Russian law in 1887. Reviews]. Kiev: Universitetskaia tipografiia Publ. (In Russian)

Vseobshchaia istoriia gosudarstva i prava [General History of State and Law]. 1947. Moscow: Iuridicheskoe izdatel'stvo, Tipografiia “Krasnyi proletarii” Publ. (In Russian)

Walker, David M. 1980. The Oxford Companion to Law. Oxford University Press.