Compliance as a legal instrument for minimizing risks and prevention of offences

Authors

  • Vladimir F. Popondopulo St. Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St. Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation
  • Dmitrii A. Petrov St. Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St. Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4096-8932

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2020.107

Abstract

The article deals with the concept and legal significance of compliance as a system of measures taken by business entities and aimed at accounting for business risks and prevention of possible offenses. The result of entrepreneurial activity cannot be guaranteed, as it depends on a variety of external and internal factors, objective and subjective causes of manifestation, which predetermine the discussion about entrepreneurial risk, its limits and mechanisms of minimization. For discussion, the author proposes the definition of compliance as a risk management system of non-compliance of an economic entity with the rules of law and all other important factors for business. The introduction of a compliance system in the activities of an economic entity should be considered as a natural need within the framework of freedom of entrepreneurial activity, and the compliance itself as an instrument of self-control of the entrepreneur. Compliance should not be equated with the tools of administrative control. The principle of voluntary compliance dictates the voluntary implementation of the compliance system, and the mandatory application of compliance procedures should be based on a risk-based approach as a special method of organization and implementation of internal control, the severity of potential negative consequences. The criterion of mandatory application for compliance procedures may be the severity of potential negative consequences of competition, rather than the type of legal form of a legal entity or participation in its authorized capital of public entities. To do this, it is necessary to develop the principles of compliance control and on their basis to introduce appropriate procedures. Within the framework of collective actions for a group of persons, the parent company of the group of persons is obliged to ensure the unity of approaches to the organization of compliance and be responsible for ensuring its effective organization.

Keywords:

compliance, business risk, entrepreneurship, offenses, self-control, control, supervision, voluntariness and obligation of compliance control, risk-oriented approach, compliance in a group of persons

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Библиография

Алеников, Александр С. 2013. «Развитие инструментария налоговой политики Российской Федерации». Автореф. дис. … канд. эконом. наук. Кубанский государственный университет.

Ассоциация антимонопольных экспертов. 2016. «Работа ФАС России над изменением законодательства в области антимонопольной деятельности. Интервью с Руководителем ФАС России И. Ю. Артемьевым». Российское конкурентное право и экономика 3: 6–11.

Бокарева, Евгения А., Наталья С. Караиван. 2018. «Антимонопольный комплаенс и перспективы его внедрения в российское законодательство». Юрист 2: 64–71.

Евсиков, Кирилл С. 2019. «Тенденции правового регулирования комплаенс-контроля в Российской Федерации». Конкурентное право 1: 11–14.

Иванова, Жанна Б. 2017. «Комплаенс и отношения права собственности субъектов предпринимательства на объекты культурного наследия». Юрист 18: 4–8.

Конкуренция и право. 2014. «Что такое антимонопольный комплаенс?». Дата обращения 10 января,2019. http://www.cljournal.ru/vibor/118.

Малыхин, Дмитрий В. 2009. «Особенности организации комплаенс-контроля в российских банках». Внутренний контроль в кредитной организации 2: 22–29.

Морковкина, Елена Б. 2005. «Комплаенс-функция в кредитных организациях». Бухгалтерия и банки 12: 47–49.

Рубцова, Наталья В. 2017. «Комплаенс как модель нормативного регулирования предпринимательской деятельности». Юрист 18: 30–33.

Тимошкин, Алексей В. 2010. «Корпоративный комплаенс-контроль как инструмент экономической безопасности». Автореф. дис. … канд. экон. наук. Институт экономики РАН.

Франскевич, Ольга П. 2018. «Комплаенс как форма саморегулирования». Юрист 1: 20–25.

Филиппович, Анна А. 2018. «Комплаенс в предпринимательской деятельности: история становления, общие положения, проблемы формирования в Российской Федерации». Вестник Университета имени О. Е. Кутафина (МГЮА) 3: 228–231.

Харисов, Ильдар К. 2011. «Внутренний аудит в системе контроля операций с облигациями». Автореф. дис. … канд. экон. наук. Казанский (Приволжский) федеральный университет.

Цепов, Георгий В. 2010. «Совершенствование правового регулирования деятельности наблюдательных советов публичных акционерных обществ в свете модернизации акционерного законодательства». Закон 5: 63–75.

Чалов, Юрий П. 2006. «Внутренний контроль в управлении рисками коммерческих банков». Автореф. дис. … канд. экон. наук. Институт экономики Российской академии наук.

Щерба, Тахир Э. 2018. «Антимонопольный комплаенс в России. Понятие. Виды». СПС «Консультант-

Плюс». Из информационного банка «Юридическая пресса». Дата обращения 20 января, 2019. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=CJI&n=114259#06979309333207595.

Lee, Paul L. 2004. “Compliance: A New Paradigm”. Banking Law Journal 121: 867–873.

Toth, Andras. 2017. “How Could Competition Authorities Reward Competition Compliance Programmes?” European Competition & Regulatory Law Review (CoRe) 4: 4–10.

References

Alenikov, Aleksandr S. 2013. “Development of tools of tax policy of the Russian Federation”. Abstract of PhD thesis in economics. Kubanskii gosudarstvennyi universitet. (In Russian)

Assotsiatsiia antimonopol’nykh ekspertov. 2016. “Work of the FAS Russia on changes in legislation in the

field of Antimonopoly activity. Interview with the Head of the FAS Russia I. Yu. Artemyev”. Rossiiskoe konkurentnoe pravo i ekonomika 3: 6–11. (In Russian)

Bokareva, Evgeniia A., Natal’ia S. Karaivan. 2018. “Antimonopoly compliance and prospects of its implementation in the Russian legislation”. Iurist 2: 64–71. (In Russian)

Chalov, Iurii P. 2006. “Internal control in risk management of commercial banks”. Abstract of PhD thesis in economics. Institut ekonomiki RAN. (In Russian)

Evsikov, Kirill S. 2019. “Trends in legal regulation of compliance control in the Russian Federation”. Konkurentnoe pravo 1: 11–14. (In Russian)

Franskevich, Ol’ga P. 2018. “Compliance as a form of self-regulation”. Iurist 1: 20–25. (In Russian)

Filippovich, Anna A. 2018. “Compliance in business: history of formation, General provisions, problems of formation in the Russian Federation”. Vestnik Universiteta imeni O. E. Kutafina (MGIuA) 3: 228–231.(In Russian)

Ivanova, Zhanna B. 2017. “Compliance and relations of ownership of business entities to cultural heritage”. Iurist 18: 4–8. (In Russian)

Kharisov, Il’dar K. 2011. “Internal audit in the control system of operations with bonds”. Abstract of PhD thesis in economics. Kazanskii (Privolzhskii) federal’nyi universitet. (In Russian)

Konkurentsiia i pravo. 2014. “What is antitrust compliance?” Accessed January 10, 2019. http://www.cljournal.ru/vibor/118. (In Russian)

Lee, Paul L. 2004. “Compliance: A New Paradigm”. Banking Law Journal 121: 867–873.

Malykhin, Dmitrii V. 2009. “Features of the organization of compliance control in Russian banks”. Vnutrennii kontrol’ v kreditnoi organizatsii 2: 22–29. (In Russian)

Morkovkina, Elena B. 2005. “Compliance function in credit institutions”. Bukhgalteriia i banki 12: 47–49.(In Russian)

Rubtsova, Natal’ia V. 2017. “Compliance as a model of normative regulation of entrepreneurial activity”. Iurist 18: 30–33. (In Russian)

Timoshkin, Aleksei V. 2010. “Corporate compliance control as a tool of economic security”. Abstract of PhD thesis in economics. Institut ekonomiki RAN. (In Russian)

Toth, Andras. 2017. “How Could Competition Authorities Reward Competition Compliance Programmes?” European Competition & Regulatory Law Review (CoRe) 4: 4–10.

Tsepov, Georgii V. 2010. “Improvement of legal regulation of Supervisory boards of public joint stock companies in the light of modernization of the joint stock legislation”. Zakon 5: 63–75. (In Russian)

Shcherba, Takhir E. 2018. “Antimonopoly compliance in Russia. Concept. Views”. SPS Konsul’tantPlius.Iz informatsionnogo banka “Iuridicheskaia pressa”. Accessed January 20, 2019. http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&base=CJI&n=114259#06979309333207595. (In Russian)

Published

2020-03-31

How to Cite

Popondopulo, V. F., & Petrov, D. A. (2020). Compliance as a legal instrument for minimizing risks and prevention of offences. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law, 11(1), 102–114. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2020.107

Issue

Section

Public and Private Law: Applied Research

Most read articles by the same author(s)