Естественное право и кризис либерального правопорядка

Виктор Петрович Кириленко; Георгий Валерьевич Алексеев; Максим Пацек

doi:10.21638/spbu14.2019.103

Authors

Виктор Петрович Кириленко North-West Institute of Management, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, 57/43, Sredny av., St. Petersburg, 199178, Russian Federation
Георгий Валерьевич Алексеев North-West Institute of Management, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, 57/43, Sredny av., St. Petersburg, 199178, Russian Federation
Максим Пацек Consulate General of the Slovak Republic in St. Petersburg, 21–2, Orbeli st., St. Petersburg, 199178, Russian Federation

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2019.103

Abstract

Structural problems in the development of a global civil society reflect the need for more equitable and harmonious legal norms aimed at effective international cooperation. Substantive scientific interest in the problems of natural law, justice and equality reflects trends in the development of the legal thought towards the creation of an integral rational theory of justice that will be effective in regulating conflicts of interests in the international system. Modern Western legal studies use various ways to solve the problem of substantiating the rationality of the established neoliberal life order and the morality that dominates in the context of the search for the way of sustainable development for the post-modern civilization. However, the discursive analysis of legal studies reflects two main trends in the development of doctrines on law and democracy: on the one hand, legal realism is determined by the imperative authority of the formal legal norms and the meaning of their judicial interpretation, and, on the other hand, commonly following the logic of natural law, the legislator always elevates to the rank of law some constructions of deontological ethics, giving them the properties of actual legal communication. Liberal discourse demonstrates a stable relationship between the quality of legal doctrine and social processes that are aimed at sustainable development. However, the rationality of narrow economic interests in the process of developing a legal system hinders the realization of fundamental natural rights and becomes one of the causes of the world community systemic social crisis.

Keywords:

law, morality, jusnaturalism, sustainable development

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография

Алексеев, Сергей С. 1995. Теория права. М.: БЕК.

Варламова, Наталия В. 2014. «Методологические проблемы современной юридической науки». Коммуникативная теория права и современные проблемы юриспруденции: К 60-летию Андрея Васильевича Полякова: в 2 т. Т. 2: Актуальные проблемы философии права и юридической науки в связи с коммуникативной теорией права. СПб.: Алеф-Пресс: 220–261.

Варламова, Наталия В. 2016. «Государство как правопорядок и правопорядок без государства». Труды Института государства и права Российской академии наук 2 (54): 89–114.

Гринберг, Руслан С. 2009. «Основная причина кризиса — крах радикального либерализма». Журнал новой экономической ассоциации 1–2: 233–235.

Гринин, Леонид Е. 2009. «Глобальный кризис как кризис перепроизводства денег». Философия и общество 1: 5–32.

Гутерреш, Антониу. 2017. Доклад Генерального секретаря о работе Организации Объединенных Наций за 2017 год. Дата обращения 16 июля, 2018. https://www.un.org/sg/ru/content/chapter-ii-promotion-sustained-economic-growth-and-sustainable-development.

Долголенко, Татьяна Н., Финогентова, Ольга Е. 2013. Аксиологический и формально-юридический смысл толкования права: монография. Екатеринбург: Изд-во УМЦ УПИ.

Дорская, Александра А. 2017. «Символы зла в истории российского права». Вестник Московского городского педагогического университета. Сер. Юридические науки 4 (28): 32–41.

Евграфова, Елизавета П. 2014. «Проблема объективности права в доктрине профессора С. С. Алексеева». Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2: 17–28.

Жуков, Вячеслав Н. 2014. «Позитивизм, социология, психология: история возникновения психолого-социологической школы права в России». Государство и право 11: 53–63.

Жуков, Вячеслав Н. 2018. «Юридическая наука и ценности». Государство и право 1: 5–16.

Зорькин, Валерий Д. 2016. Доверие к праву — путь разрешения глобальных кризисов. Лекция для участников Международного юридического форума. Санкт-Петербург. 19 мая 2016 г. Дата обращения 16 июля, 2018. https://rg.ru/2016/05/19/valerij-zorkin-zapadnye-elity-naviazyvaiut-miruchuzhdye-narodu-cennosti.html.

Казыдуб, Надежда Н. 2009. «Аксиологические системы в языке и речи». Вестник Иркутского государственного лингвистического университета 2: 132–137.

Кельзен, Ганс. 1987. Чистое учение о праве Ганса Кельзена. М.: ИНИОН РАН.

Козлихин, Игорь Ю. 2000. «Позитивизм и естественное право». Государство и право 3: 5–11.

Кузнецов, Эдуард. В. 1993. «Естественное право как фактор духовного возрождения России». Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 4: 75–79.

Любашиц, Валентин Я., Разуваев, Николай В. 2018. Эволюция государства: историческая динамика и теоретическая модель: монография. М.: Инфра-М.

Малышева, Наталья И., Пустынникова, Татьяна И. 2017. «Идейные основы глобального и регионального правопорядков: перспективы естественно-правовой концепции». Российский ежегодник международного права: 180–198.

Марченко, Михаил Н. 2012. «О соотношении права и закона в правовом государстве». Российское правосудие 5: 6–15.

Марченко, Михаил Н. 2014. «О влиянии процессов глобализации и регионализации на развитие права и его теории». Вестник алтайской академии экономики и права 6: 9–17.

Момотов, Виктор В. 2018. «Принципы справедливости и целесообразности в институтах англо-американских и континентально-европейских правопорядков». Российское правосудие 1 (141): 35–48.

Нерсесянц, Владик C. 2002. «Философия права: либертарно-юридическая концепция». Вопросы философии 3: 3–15.

Печерская, Наталия В. 2001. «Метаморфозы справедливости: историко-этимологический анализ понятия справедливости в русской культуре». Полис. Политические исследования 2: 132–146.

Поляков, Андрей В. 2014a. Коммуникативное правопонимание: избранные труды. СПб.: Алеф-Пресс.

Поляков, Андрей В. 2014b. «Правопонимание как теоретико-правовая проблема». Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 2: 6–18.

Поляков, Андрей В. 2015. «Возможно ли возрождение идеи естественного права в России?». Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 5: 6–16.

Тихомиров, Лев А. 1905. Монархическая государственность. М.: Университетская типография.

Финогентова, Ольга Е. 2017. «Соотношение права и закона в свете проблемы правового государства». Правовое государство: теория и практика 2 (48): 20–25.

Alexander, Larry. 2010. “Plastic Trees and Gladiators: Liberalism and Aesthetic Regulation”. Legal Theory 16 (2): 77–90.

Billingham, Paul, Taylor, Anthony. 2018. “Liberal Perfectionism, Moral Integrity, and Self-Respect”. The American Journal of Jurisprudence 63 (1): 63–79.

Cicero, Marcus Tullius, 1971. Selected Works. Penguin Books.

Dagan, Hanoch. 2018. “The Real Legacy of American Legal Realism”. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 38 (1): 123–146.

Dworkin, Ronald M. 1986. Law’s Empire. London: Harvard University Press.

Dworkin, Ronald M. 2006. Justice in Robes. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Ferzan, Kimberly K., Morse, Stephen J. (eds). 2016. Legal, Moral, and Metaphysical Truth: The Philosophy of Michael S. Moore. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Finnis, John M. 1980. Natural Law and Natural Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

González, Ana M. 2008. Contemporary Perspectives on Natural Law. Ashgate.

Guerin, Daniel. 1970. Anarchism: From Theory to Practice. Introduction by Noam Chomsky. Monthly Review Press.

Habermas, Jürgen. 1984. The Theory of Communicative Action Vol. 1. Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Transl. by Thomas McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press.

Habermas, Jürgen. 1987. The Theory of Communicative Action Vol. 2. Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Transl. by Thomas McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press.

Hart, Herbert L. A. 1961. The Concept of Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Irving, Kristol 1971. “Pornography, Obscenity and the Case for Censorship”. The New York Times March 28: 24.

Keyes, Evelyn. 2012. “Two Conceptions of Judicial Integrity: Traditional and Perfectionist Approaches to Issues of Morality and Social Justice”. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy 22 (2): 233–303.

Kotz, David M. 2015. The Rise and Fall of Neoliberal Capitalism. Harvard University Press.

Kramer, Matthew H. 2017. Liberalism with Excellence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Leiter, Brian. 2015. “Legal Realism and Legal Doctrine”. University of Chicago Public Law & Legal Theory. Working Paper (528).

Moore, Michael S. 2001. “Justifying the Natural Law Theory of Constitutional Interpretation”. Fordham Law Review 69 (5): 2087–2117.

Nielsen, Kai. 1991. God and the Grounding of Morality. University of Ottawa Press.

Quong, Jonathan. 2011. Liberalism without Perfection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ramsay, Marc. 2017. “Slaves, Gladiators, and Death: Kantian Liberalism and the Moral Limits of Consent”. Legal Theory 23 (2): 96–131.

Rawls, John B. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Raz, Joseph. 1986. The Morality of Freedom. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Ripstein, Arthur. 2001. Equality, Responsibility, and the Law. Cambridge Studies in Philosophy and Law.

Ripstein, Arthur. 2009. Force and Freedom: Kant's Legal and Political Philosophy. Harvard University Press.

Rothbard, Murray N. 1982. The Ethics of Liberty. Humanities Press.

Sztompka, Piotr. 1999. Trust: A Sociological Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Tamanaha, Brian Z. 2017. A Realistic Theory of Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Vujadinovic, Dragica. 2012. “Ronald Dworkin — Theory of Justice”. European Scientific Journal 8 (2): 1–13.

Weinreb, Lloyd L. 1996. “The Moral Point of View in Natural Law”. Liberalism, and Morality, ed. Robert P. George. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

References

Alekseev, Sergei S. 1995. Teoriia prava [The Theory of Law]. Moscow: BEK Publ. (In Russian)

Alexander, Larry. 2010. “Plastic Trees and Gladiators: Liberalism and Aesthetic Regulation”. Legal Theory 16 (2): 77–90.

Billingham, Paul, Taylor, Anthony. 2018. “Liberal Perfectionism, Moral Integrity, and Self-Respect”. The American Journal of Jurisprudence 63 (1): 63–79.

Cicero, Marcus Tullius, 1971. Selected Works. Penguin Books.

Dagan, Hanoch. 2018. “The Real Legacy of American Legal Realism”. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 38 (1): 123–146.

Dolgolenko, Tat'iana N., Finogentova, Ol'ga E. 2013. Aksiologicheskii i formal'no-iuridicheskii smysl tolkovaniia prava: monografiia [The axiological and formal legal meaning of the interpretation of law: monograph]. Ekaterinburg: Publishing house of UTI. (In Russian)

Dorskaia, Aleksandra A. 2017. “Simvoly zla v istorii rossiiskogo prava” [“Symbols of Evil in the History of Russian Law”]. Vestnik Moskovskogo gorodskogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. Ser. Iuridicheskie nauki[Bulletin of the Moscow City Pedagogical University. Series: Juridical sciences] 4 (28): 32–41. (In Russian)

Dworkin, Ronald M. 1986. Law’s Empire. London: Harvard University Press.

Dworkin, Ronald M. 2006. Justice in Robes. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Evgrafova, Elizaveta P. 2014. “Problema ob"ektivnosti prava v doktrine professora S. S. Alekseeva” [“The problem of the objectivity of law in the doctrine of Professor S. S. Alekseev”] Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki [The Law. Journal of Higher School of Economics] 2: 17–28. (In Russian)

Ferzan, Kimberly K., Morse, Stephen J. (eds). 2016. Legal, Moral, and Metaphysical Truth: The Philosophy of Michael S. Moore. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Finnis, John M. 1980. Natural Law and Natural Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Finogentova, Ol'ga E. 2017. “Sootnoshenie prava i zakona v svete problemy pravovogo gosudarstva” [“The correlation of law and law in the light of the problem of the rule of law”]. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teoriia i praktika [The rule of law: theory and practice] 2 (48): 20–25. (In Russian)

Grinberg, Ruslan S. 2009. “Osnovnaia prichina krizisa — krakh radikal'nogo liberalizma” [“The main cause of the crisis is a collapse of radical liberalism”]. Zhurnal novoi ekonomicheskoi assotsiatsii [Journal of the New Economic Association] 1–2: 233–235. (In Russian)

Grinin, Leonid E. 2009. “Global'nyi krizis kak krizis pereproizvodstva deneg” [“The Global Crisis as a Crisis of Overproduction of Money”]. Filosofiia i obshchestvo [Philosophy and Society] 1: 5–32. (In Russian)

González, Ana M. 2008. Contemporary Perspectives on Natural Law. Ashgate.

Guerin, Daniel. 1970. Anarchism: From Theory to Practice. Introduction by Noam Chomsky. Monthly Review Press.

Habermas, Jürgen. 1984. The Theory of Communicative Action Vol. 1. Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Transl. by Thomas McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press.

Habermas, Jürgen. 1987. The Theory of Communicative Action Vol. 2. Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Transl. by Thomas McCarthy. Boston: Beacon Press.

Hart, Herbert L. A. 1961. The Concept of Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Irving, Kristol 1971. “Pornography, Obscenity and the Case for Censorship”. The New York Times March 28: 24.

Kazydub Nadezhda. N. 2009. “Aksiologicheskie sistemy v iazyke i rechi” [“Axiological systems in language and speech”]. Vestnik Irkutskogo gosudarstvennogo lingvisticheskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Irkutsk State Linguistic University] 2: 132–137. (In Russian)

Kel'zen, Gans. 1987. Chistoe uchenie o prave Gansa Kel'zena [Pure Doctrine of the Law of Hans Kelsen]. Moscow: INION RAN Publ. (In Russian)

Keyes, Evelyn. 2012. “Two Conceptions of Judicial Integrity: Traditional and Perfectionist Approaches to Issues of Morality and Social Justice”. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy 22 (2): 233–303.

Kotz, David M. 2015. The Rise and Fall of Neoliberal Capitalism. Harvard University Press.

Kozlikhin, Igor' Iu. 2000. “Pozitivizm i estestvennoe pravo” [“Positivism and Natural Law”]. Gosudarstvo i parvo [State and Law] 3: 5–11. (In Russian)

Kramer, Matthew H. 2017. Liberalism with Excellence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kuznetsov, Eduard V. 1993. “Estestvennoe pravo kak faktor dukhovnogo vozrozhdeniia Rossii” [“Natural Law as a Factor of the Spiritual Revival of Russia”]. Izvestiia vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Pravovedenie[News of Higher Educational Institutions. Jurisprudence] 4: 75–79. (In Russian)

Leiter, Brian. 2015. “Legal Realism and Legal Doctrine”. University of Chicago Public Law & Legal Theory. Working Paper (528).

Liubashits, Valentin Ia., Razuvaev, Nikolai V. 2018. Evoliutsiia gosudarstva: istoricheskaia dinamika i teoreticheskaia model': monografiia [Evolution of the state: historical dynamics and theoretical model: monograph]. Moscow: Infra-M Publ. (In Russian)

Malysheva, Natal'ia I., Pustynnikova, Tat'iana I. 2017. “Ideinye osnovy global'nogo i regional'nogo pravoporiadkov: perspektivy estestvenno-pravovoi kontseptsii” [“Ideological foundations of global and regional law and order: perspectives of the natural-legal concept”]. Rossiiskii ezhegodnik mezhdunarodnogo prava [Russian Yearbook of International Law] 2016: 180–198. (In Russian)

Marchenko, Mikhail N. 2012. “O sootnoshenii prava i zakona v pravovom gosudarstve” [“On the relationship of law and law in a law-based state”]. Rossiiskoe pravosudie [Russian justice] 5: 6–15. (In Russian)

Marchenko, Mikhail N. 2014. “O vliianii protsessov globalizatsii i regionalizatsii na razvitie prava i ego teorii” [“On the influence of the processes of globalization and regionalization on the development of law and its theory”]. Vestnik Altaiskoi akademii ekonomiki i prava [Bulletin of the Altai Academy of Economics and Law] 6: 9–17. (In Russian)

Momotov, Viktor V. 2018. “Printsipy spravedlivosti i tselesoobraznosti v institutakh anglo-amerikanskikh i kontinental'no-evropeiskikh pravoporiadkov” [“Principles of justice and expediency in the institutions of Anglo-American and Continental European law and order”]. Rossiiskoe pravosudie [Russian justice] 1 (141): 35–48. (In Russian)

Moore, Michael S. 2001. “Justifying the Natural Law Theory of Constitutional Interpretation”. Fordham Law Review 69 (5): 2087–2117.

Nersesiants, Vladik C. 2002. “Filosofiia prava: libertarno-iuridicheskaia kontseptsiia” [“Philosophy of law: libertarian-legal concept”]. Voprosy filosofii [Questions of Philosophy] 3: 3–15. (In Russian)

Nielsen, Kai. 1991. God and the Grounding of Morality. University of Ottawa Press.

Pecherskaia, Nataliia V. 2001. “Metamorfozy spravedlivosti: istoriko-etimologicheskii analiz poniatiia spravedlivosti v russkoi kul'ture” [“Metamorphoses of justice: historical and etymological analysis of the notion of justice in Russian culture”]. Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniia [Polis. Political studies] 2: 132–146. (In Russian)

Poliakov, Andrei V. 2014a. Kommunikativnoe pravoponimanie: izbrannye trudy [Communicative legal understanding: selected works]. St. Petersburg: Alef-Press Publ. (In Russian)

Poliakov, Andrei V. 2014b. “Pravoponimanie kak teoretiko-pravovaia problema” [“Legal understanding as a theoretical and legal problem”]. Izvestiia vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Pravovedenie [News of Higher Educational Institutions. Jurisprudence] 2 (313): 6–18. (In Russian)

Poliakov, Andrei V. 2015. “Vozmozhno li vozrozhdenie idei estestvennogo prava v Rossii?” [“Is it possible to revive the idea of natural law in Russia?”]. Izvestiia vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Pravovedenie [News of Higher Educational Institutions. Jurisprudence] 5 (322): 6–16. (In Russian)