Legal entities classification models in the Russian Federation and China

Authors

  • Тяньфан Ян Office 501, 1a Shennan st., Gaoxin District, Shengzhen, 518057, The People’s Republic of China

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu14.2018.206

Abstract

The author of the article applies the method of comparative historical and modern analysis to trace the classifications of legal entities, which have evolved in different stages of development of the Russian Federation and China. The latter has chosen a “progressive” way of reforming the transition from a planned economy to a market economy, and Russia completely abandoned the Soviet model, using “shock therapy” to implement reforms. From a legislative point of view, Russia tried to abandon the Soviet model, and China still adhered to certain provisions that have remained since the Stalin era. In spite of the fact that the Chinese “progressive” approach more protected the economy from instability, in the area of designing the legal system, China has not fully completed the transition to a market economy. Searching for suitable models, both countries gradually got rid of the Soviet model of planned economy classification. After 40 years of implementing the policy of Reform and Opening, economic construction in China has achieved brilliant results. China is currently amending the classification of legal entities, and we should pay attention to it, as well as conduct research and comparison. Now the promulgation of the Civil Code (general part) of China has caused the previous state to be broken. The new corporate classification model is undoubtedly a new breakthrough. Russia has also formed its own classification model of legal entities. As a result, the legal entities classification in these countries has become closer again, however each country still possesses its own features.

Keywords:

classification, legal entity, China, law, comparison, China’s Corpus of civil law, model

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Библиография

蔡立东. 2012. «法人分类模式的立法选择». 法律科学(西北政法大学学报). 第1期: 108–116页. [Цай, Лидон. 2012. «Выборы классифицированных моделей юридических лиц». Юридическая наука 1: 108–116].

范健, 张虹玉, 梁泽宇. 2016. «一带一路»与中国商法国际化的新挑战. 深化法律合作,共建一带一路·论文集. 中国法学会. 西安. 中国. [Фан, Цянь, Чжан, Хунюй, Лян, Зэюй. 2016. Новые вызовы для проекта «Один пояс, один путь» и интернационализации коммерческого права в Китае: сб. эссе. Углубление правового сотрудничества и совместное строительство одного пояса, одного пути. Си’ан: Китайская юридическая ассоциация].

[日] 铃木贤:2006. «原苏联法制与法学对当前中国之影响». 俄罗斯法论丛. 哈尔滨. 中国. [Сузуки, Кэн. 2006. Влияние советского права на китайское право: сб. статей о российской юриспруденции. Харбин].

佟柔. 2008. 中国民法学·民法总则. 北京.:中国人民法院出版社. [Тон, Жоу. 2008. Китайская юриспруденция: общие положения гражданского права. Пекин: Издательский дом Китайского народного суда].

王志华. 2008. «苏联法影响中国法的几点思考». 华东政法大学学报. 第1期:95–100页. [Ван, Чжихуа. 2008. «О влиянии советского права на китайское право». Вестник Восточно-Китайского университета политики и права 1: 95–100].

夏利民. 2007. «论财团法人制度». 博士论文. 中国对外经济贸易大学. [Ся, Лиминь. 2007. Исследование института фондов — юридических лиц. Автореф. дис. … д-ра юрид. наук. Университет внешней экономики и торговли Китая].

鄢一美. 2006. 当代俄罗斯民法研究. 北京.:中国政法大学出版社. [Янь, Имэй. 2006. Исследование современного российского гражданского права. Пекин: Издательский дом Китайского университета политики и права].

Галихайдаров, Евгений В. 2010. Сравнительно-правовое исследование коммерческих организаций КНР и России. Современное право 6: 132–136.

Макарова, Ольга А. 2015. Корпоративное право: учебник и практикум для бакалавриата и магистратуры. М.: Юрайт.

Муромцева, Зоя А., Шао, Жань. 2017. Государственные предприятия КНР: реформы и развитие. М.: ИДВ РАН.

Попондопуло, Владимир Ф. 2016. Коммерческое (предпринимательское) право: учебник: в 2 т. Под ред. В. Ф. Попондопуло. Т. 2. М.: Проспект.

References

Cai li dong. 2012. Faren fenlei moshi de lifa xuanze. Falv: ke xue (xibei zheng fa da xuexue bao). Di yi qi 108–116 ye. [Cai, Lidong. 2012. Election of Legal Entities Classification Models. Juridical Science(China) 1: 108–116]. (In Chinese)

Fan Jian, Zhang Hong yu, Liang ze yu. 2016. Yu yidai yilu lu yu zhongguo shang faguo jihua dexin tiaozhan. Shenhua falu: hezuo,gong jian yidai yilu: lunwen ji. zhong guo fa xuehui. Xian1. Zhongguo. [Fan, Jian, Zhang, Hongyu, Liang, Zeyu. 2016. New Challenges for The Belt and Road Initiative and the Internationalization of Commercial Law in China. Collecting an essay: Deepening Legal Cooperation of The Belt and Road Initiative. Xi’an]. (In Chinese)

Galikhaydarov, E. V., 2010. “Sravnitel’no-pravovoe issledovanie kommercheskikh organizatsii KNR i Rossii”[“Comparative Legal Study of Commercial Organizations of the People’s Republic of China and Russia”]. Sovremennoe pravo [Modern law] 6: 132–136. (In Russian)

Makarova, Olga A. 2015. Korporativnoe pravo: uchebnik i praktikum dlia bakalavriata i magistratury [Corporate Law: A Textbook and a Workshop for Bachelor and Master’s]. Moscow: Yurayt Press. (In Russian)

Muromtseva Zoya, Shao Zhan. 2017. Gosudarstvennye predpriiatiia KNR: reformy i razvitie [State Enterprises of the People’s Republic of China: reforms and development]. Moscow: IFES RAS. (In Russian)

Popondopulo, Vladimir. 2016. Kommercheskoe (predprinimatel’skoe) pravo: uchebnik: v 2 t. [Commercial(Entrepreneurial) Law]. In 2 vols. Vol. 2. Moscow: Prospect Press. (In Russian)

[Ri] Lingmu Xian. 2006. Yuan sulian fazhi yu faxue dui dangqian zhongguo zhi yingxiang xiang. e luo si fa lun cong. ha erbin. Zhong guo. [Suzuki, Ken (Japan). 2006. The Influence of Soviet Law on Chinese Law. Articles about Russian Jurisprudence. Harbin]. (In Chinese)

Tong rou. 2008. Zhong guomin faxue minfa zongze. beijing: zhong guo ren min fayuan chu banshe. [Tong,Rou. Chinese Jurisprudence: General Provisions of Civil Law. Beijing: Chinese People’s Court Press].(In Chinese)

Wang zhi hua. 2008. Huasu lian fa yingxiang zhong guofa de jidian sikao kao. Huadong zheng fa da xuexue bao. Di qi1 qi: 95–100 ye. [Wang, Zhihua. 2008. On the Influence of Soviet Law on Chinese Law. Journal of the East China University of Politics and Law (China) 1: 95–100]. (In Chinese)

Хiali min. 2007. Min lun caituan faren zhidu du. boshi lunwen. zhongguo dui wai jing ji mao yi daxue. [Xia, Limin. 2007. Investigation of the Institution of Funds — Legal Entities. PhD diss., University of International Business and Economics, China].(In Chinese)

Yan yi mei. 2006. Dang dai e luo si min fa yan jiu. Bei jing: zhong guo zheng fa da xue chu ban she. [Yan, Yimei. 2006. The Study of Russian Modern Civil Law. Beijing: Publishing House of the Chinese University of Politics and Law].(In Chinese)

Published

2018-06-15

How to Cite

Ян, Т. (2018). Legal entities classification models in the Russian Federation and China. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law, 9(2), 203–214. https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu14.2018.206

Issue

Section

Comparative Law