Основания отмены или изменения судебных решений по уголовным делам в апелляционном порядке

Aleksandr M. Panokin

doi:10.21638/spbu14.2021.104

Authors

Aleksandr M. Panokin Kutafin Moscow State Law University, 9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya ul., Moscow, 125993, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9967-7171

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2021.104

Abstract

The article analyzes the legal regulation and practice of applying the grounds of appeal. The positive and negative sides of the statutory recognition of the grounds of appeal are revealed. The author comes to the conclusion that when establishing such grounds in the Criminal Procedural Code of the Russian Federation, the rules of formal logic and systematization of legislation were violated. The grounds of appeal do not form a unified system, they do not cover all possible violations that entail the delivery of unjust court decisions. As a result of the study, it can be affirmed that the absence of appeal grounds will protect the rights of the individual in criminal proceedings to the maximum extent by maximizing the extension of the subject of the appeal and verification of court decisions, and it will provide ample opportunity for the court of appeal to identify and eliminate any violations committed. In addition to this, it is necessary to increase the requirements for the reasoning of appeals, representations of professional participants in criminal procedures and the quality of the justification and motivation of decisions by courts of appeal. The absence of the grounds of appeal makes it necessary to provide a detailed answer to the arguments of the subjects of the appeal set out in the complaints, as a result of which the decision of the court of appeal becomes not only legal, reasonable, motivated and fair, but also convincing. Equally, the absence of such grounds guarantees the independence of judges and their high professionalism, as well as the demand for creative potential when reviewing court decisions. In turn, the consolidation in the criminal procedure law of various grounds for reviewing court decisions that have entered into legal force will make it possible to limit separate control and verification stages of the criminal process from each other.

Keywords:

grounds of appeal, subject of the appeal, subject of verification, court decisions, appeal, criminal process

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография

Андреева, Ольга И., Ольга В. Желева, Анастасия А. Рукавишникова, Татьяна В. Трубникова. 2016. «Право на возвращение уголовного дела судом апелляционной инстанции в суд первой инстанции: возможность злоупотребления полномочиями». Всероссийский криминологический журнал 10 (3): 554–567.

Анохин, Петр К. 1978. Избранные труды. Философские аспекты теории функциональной системы. М.: Наука.

Борисевич, Галина Я. 2013. «О существенных, неустранимых, фундаментальных нарушениях закона как основаниях отмены или изменения судебных решений по уголовным делам». Вестник Пермского университета. Юридические науки 2: 199–210.

Валеев, Артем Т. 2016. Обжалование и пересмотр судебных решений по уголовным делам. М.: Юрлитинформ.

Воскобитова, Лидия А. 2012. «Основания отмены или изменения приговора в апелляционной инстанции». Lex Russica 5: 976–991.

Давыдов, Владимир А., Оксана В. Качалова. 2018. «Современные тенденции развития российского уголовного судопроизводства». Вестник Томского государственного университета. Право 29: 69–78.

Кардозо, Бенджамин Н. 2017. Природа судейской деятельности. М.: Статут.

Назаров, Александр Д. 2017. «Следственные и судебные ошибки и уголовно-процессуальный механизм их устранения: концептуальные основы». Дис. … д-ра юрид. наук. СПб.: Санкт-Петербургский государственный университет.

Панокин, Александр М. 2018. «Конкуренция уголовно-процессуальных норм, регулирующих основания отмены или изменения судебного решения в апелляционном порядке». Вестник Университета имени О. Е. Кутафина (МГЮА) 2 (42): 105–113.

Плашевская, Анастасия А. 2012. «Апелляционный порядок проверки судебного приговора по уголовному делу в соответствии с ФЗ от 29 декабря 2010 г.: проблемные перспективы». Вестник Томского государственного университета 363: 140–143.

Поздняков, Михаил Л. 2015. Система оснований отмены и изменения судебных актов в российском уголовном процессе. М.: Юрлитинформ.

References

Andreeva, Ol’ga I., Ol’ga V. Zheleva, Anastasiia A. Rukavishnikova, Tat’iana V. Trubnikova. 2016. “The right to return a criminal case by a court of appeal to a court of first instance: the possibility of abuse of authority”. Vserossiiskii kriminologicheskii zhurnal 10 (3): 554–567. (In Russian)

Anokhin, Petr K. 1978. Selected Works. Philosophical aspects of the theory of a functional system. Moscow, Nauka Publ. (In Russian)

Borisevich, Galina Ia. 2013. “On substantial, irremovable, fundamental violations of the law as reasons for the cancellation or amendment of court decisions in criminal matters”. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Iuridicheskie nauki 2: 199–210. (In Russian)

Cardozo, Benjamin N. 2017. The Nature of the Judicial Process. Rus. ed. Moscow, Statut Publ. (In Russian)

Davydov, Vladimir A., Oksana V. Kachalova. 2018. “Current trends in the development of Russian criminal proceedings”. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo 29: 69–78. (In Russian)

Nazarov, Aleksandr D. 2017. “Investigative and judicial errors and the criminal procedural mechanism for their elimination: conceptual foundations”. Dr. Sci. Diss. St. Petersburg, Sankt-Peterburgskii gosudarstvennyi universitet. (In Russian)

Panokin, Aleksandr M. 2018. “The competition between the criminally-remedial norms regulating the cancellation or change of a court judgment under appeal procedure”. Vestnik Universiteta imeni O. E. Kutafina(MGIuA) 2 (42): 105–113. (In Russian)

Plashevskaia, Anastasiia A. 2012. “Appeal procedure for verifying a court sentence in a criminal case in accordance with the Federal Law of December 29, 2010: problematic prospects”. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 363: 140–143. (In Russian)

Pozdniakov, Mikhail L. 2015. The system of reasons for cancellation and amendment of judicial acts in the Russian criminal process. Moscow, Iurlitinform Publ. (In Russian)

Valeev, Artem T. 2016. Appeal and review of court decisions in criminal matters. Moscow, Iurlitinform Publ.(In Russian)

Voskobitova, Lidiia A. 2012. “Reasons for the cancellation or change of sentence in the court of appeal”. Lex Russica 5: 976–991. (In Russian)