Evolution of the concept of genocide through the lens of modern “memory wars”: International legal and intrastate dimensions

Aleksandra A. Dorskaia; Andrei Yu. Dorskii

doi:10.21638/spbu14.2023.115

Authors

Aleksandra A. Dorskaia The North-Western Branch of the Russian State University of Justice, 5, Alexandrovsky park, St Petersburg, 197046, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8723-8673
Andrei Yu. Dorskii St Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0991-2941

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2023.115

Abstract

The article examines how the concept of genocide has evolved at the international and national legal levels, beginning with its origins at the doctrinal level and culminating in international conventions and national regulatory acts. Challenges regarding the definition of genocide and ambiguous interpretation of genocide in relation to crimes against humanity were identified. It is demonstrated that international justice bodies interpret the concept of genocide differently. The study concluded that humanity did not fully utilize the potential of the United Nations and International Criminal Tribunals in order to develop a joint measured approach to assessing historical events, specifically World War II and the genocide in 1939–1945, in the context of actualizing history and triggering memory wars. The positions of states to consolidate the crime of genocide in criminal legislation are considered: compliance with the definition of genocide in international conventions, extension of the list of groups against whose members the genocide can be committed, leaving the list open as to which groups can be included. The preferences of the second option are shown. Examples of states turning to the facts of genocide committed in the past are given (for instance, Armenia towards Turkey, Namibia towards Germany, Poland towards Germany and Russia, Russia towards Germany and its allies during World War II), and it has been suggested that the material responsibility of states cannot be applied to events before 1945, since the desire to avoid it leads to non-recognition of political international-legal responsibility.

Keywords:

genocide, international crime, official remembrance policy, memory wars, self-identification of states, self-identification of peoples

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

References

Alimov, Kairulla G., Kuandyk K. Alimov. 2015. “Grain genocide of Russia”. AgroSnabForum 11 (139): 58–61.(In Russian)

Al’tman, Il’ya A. 2022. “Genocide against all”. Nezavisimaia gazeta 127 (8466): 7. (In Russian)

Buryachkova, Elena G. 2015. “Genocide: Historical aspects”. Innovatsionnye tekhnologii v nauke i obrazovanii 1 (1): 22–23. (In Russian)

Cevek, Judit I., Péter T. Veres. 2016. “Holodomor in Ukraine the worst genocide in the Soviet Union (controversial issues around the definition of genocide)”. Veles 9–1 (39): 11–18.

Chernovitskaya, Yuliya V. 2015. “Historical genocide and modern genocide: the problem of responsibility”. In Materialy ezhegodnykh Moiseevskikh chtenii. Vol. 4, 62–69. Moscow, Akademiia MNEPU Publ.(In Russian)

Kazyrytski, Leanid. 2022. “Francoist repression in Spain and the crime of genocide”. Criminology and Criminal Justice 5 (22): 676-693. https://doi.org/10.1177/17488958211017385

Kolosov, Yurii M., Emiliia S. Krivchikova, eds. 1997. Current international law. In 3 vols, vol. 3. Moscow, Moskovskii nezavisimiyi institut mezhdunarodnogo prava Publ. (In Russian)

Krasnitskaya, Anna N. 2015. “Genocide of Ukrainian culture in the second half of the nineteenth century”. Gileia: nauchnyi vestnik 96: 30–33. (In Russian)

Lemkin, Raphael. 1944. Axis rule in occupied Europe: Laws of occupation, analysis of government, proposals for redress. Washington, Carnegie Endowment for World Peace.

Lemkin, Raphael. 1945. “Genocide — A modern crime”. Free World 4: 39–43.

Marukyan, Armen Ts. 2017. “Value of the Joint Declaration of Powers of the Entente of May 24, 1915, in the question of qualification of Armenian genocide and its impact on the authorities of the Ottoman Empire”. Gumanitarnye i iuridicheskie issledovaniia 3: 71–75. (In Russian)

Matulewska, Aleksandra, Dariusz J. Gwiazdowicz. 2022. “In quest of genocide understanding: Multiple faces of genocide”. International Journal for the Semiotics of Law — Revue internationale de Sémiotique juridique 35: 1425–1443. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11196-021-09847-5

McGuire, Michaela M., Danielle J. Murdoch. 2022. “(In)-justice: An exploration of the dehumanization, victimization, criminalization, and over-incarceration of indigenous women in Canada”. Punishment and Society 4 (24): 529–550. https://doi.org/10.1177/14624745211001685

Mettraux, Guénaél. 2006. “Genocide and crimes against humanity”. International Crimes and the Ad Hoc Tribunals, 329–340. Oxford, Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199207541.003.0026

Murray, Alexander R. J. 2011. “Does international criminal law still require a ‘crime of crimes’? A comparative review of genocide and crimes against humanity”. Goettingen Journal of International Law 3 (2): 589–615.

O’Connor, Vivienne M., Colette Rausch, Hans-Jörg Albrecht, eds. 2007–2008. Model codes for post-conflict criminal justice. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Washington, D. C., United States Institute of Peace.

Ratner, Steven R. 2007. “Can we compare evils? The enduring debate on genocide and crimes against humanity”. Washington University Global Studies Law Review 3 (6): 583–589.

Rekunkov, Aleksandr M., ed. 1987–1999. “The Charter of the International Military Tribunal”. Niurenbergskii tribunal. In 8 vols, vol. 8, 146–153. Moscow, Iuridicheskaia literatura Publ. (In Russian)

Stanton, Gregory H. 2016. “10 stages of genocide”. Genocide Watch. Accessed October 17, 2022. http://genocidewatch.net/genocide-2/8-stages-of-genocide.

Šturma, Pavel, Milan Lipovskỳ, eds. 2022. The crime of genocide: Then and now: Evolution of a crime. Leiden, Brill, Nijhoff.

Tarbagaev, Aleksey N., Georgy L. Moskalev. 2016. “Key directions for modernizing the norm on criminal liability for genocide in the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation”. Vserossiiskii kriminologicheskii zhurnal 3 (10): 511–520. (In Russian)

Trainin, Aron N. 1956. Protecting peace and combating crimes against humanity. Moscow, Academy of Sciences of the SSSR Press. (In Russian)

Veres, Péter. 2015. “Controversial issues around definition of “crimes against humanity” (genocide) the eyes of historians”. Vestnik Permskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitarno-pedagogicheskogo universiteta. Ser. 3. Gumanitarnye i obshchestvennye nauki 1: 62–73. (In Russian)