Legal aspects of liability for Holocaust denial in Russia (through the prism of Roman Yushkov case)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2023.303Abstract
The article expounds upon the issue of Holocaust denial and freedom of expression in the context of Roman Yushkov Case, who posted a link on his social network page to the article claiming that the number of victims of the Holocaust is greatly exaggerated and well below six million. Roman Yushkov’s was charged under Art. 281 Part 1 and Art. 3541 Part 1 of the Russian Criminal Code. A Jury acquitted him, having considered the arguments provided by the defence about Yushkov’s intentions only to stimulate a public debate about the number of the Holocaust victims by his publications. The Supreme Court upheld this decision. In this paper will examine the history and development of Holocaust denial, will examine Holocaust and other genocides laws globally. The author describe how the trend of the revisionism. Revisionism is an academic approach that recognizes that traditional narratives of history may not be entirely accurate and should be reviewed and revised as new information comes to the surface. At the national level have enacted a variety of laws, ranging the criminalize Holocaust denial and other genocides, Nazi ideology promoted through speech, symbols or public association or can be used to prosecute individuals who deny the Holocaust. These laws are intended to prevent the return any public reemergence of Nazi views. There are now essentially four types of regimes in this domain, in terms of scope of the offence of genocide denial. Most nations of the European Union (as well as Israel and Russian Federation) criminalize Holocaust denial. Despite the threat of criminal prosecution, however, Holocaust denial have taken on a cult-like following of their own on the internet. The article concludes about the contradictory of Russian law enforcement practice, Russian judicial system drawbacks, as well the system preparation of representatives of the legal profession.
Keywords:
Holocaust denial, historical revisionism, genocide denial, rehabilitation of Nazism, international case-law, Russian case-law, freedom of expression, human rights
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Библиография
Альтман, Илья А. 2022. История Холокоста и геноцидов. XX век. М.: МИК. Дата обращения 25 июня,2023. https://holocf.ru/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Holokost_2022-02-13_out-1.pdf.
Арамян, Арам Ж. 2016. «Некоторые проблемы применения статьи 17 в делах об отрицании Холокоста в практике Европейского суда по правам человека». Вестник Российско-Армянского (Славянского) университета. Серия: гуманитарные и общественные науки 1 (22): 14–20.
Благин, Антон. 2015. «Евреи! Верните немцам деньги за мошенничество с “Holocaust six millions Jews”!». LiveJournal. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://blagin-anton.livejournal.com/666403.html.
Вавилова, Кристина А. 2015. «Развитие ревизионистской мысли в отечественной историографии Холокоста». Вестник Кемеровского государственного университета 1–3 (61): 132–136.
Варченко, Игорь А., Лариса Г. Литвяк. 2015. «Уголовное законодательство зарубежных стран об ответственности за преступления, аналогичные ст. 354.1 УК РФ “Реабилитация нацизма”(часть 2)». Гуманитарные, социально-экономические и общественные науки 11 (1): 257–260.
Ветошкина, Екатерина Д. 2020. «Отрицание Холокоста: социальная обусловленность и сравнительный анализ уголовно-правового запрета». Lex Russica 11 (168): 129–138. https://doi.org/10.17803/1729-5920.2020.168.11.129-138
Головненков, Павел В. 2021. Уголовное Уложение Федеративной Республики Германия — Strafgesetzbuch(StGB). Научно-практический комментарий и перевод текста закона. Потсдам: Изд-во Потсдамского ун-та. https://doi.org/10.25932/publishup-47371
Гудков, Лев Д., Наталия А. Зоркая, Екатерина В. Кочергина, Евгения В. Лезина. 2016. «Антисемитизм в структуре массовой ксенофобии в России: негативная идентичность и потенциал мобилизации». Вестник общественного мнения. Данные. Анализ. Дискуссии 1–2 (122): 140–197.
Додонов, Вячеслав Н. 2014. «Уголовно-правовая охрана исторической правды: зарубежный опыт и развитие российского законодательства». Вестник Академии Генеральной прокуратуры Российской Федерации 3 (41): 87–96.
Земсков, Виктор Н. 2015. «Остается ли дискуссионным вопрос о масштабах людских потерь СССР в 1941–1945 гг.?». Известия Самарского научного центра Российской академии наук 17 (3): 115–127. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. http://www.ssc.smr.ru/media/journals/izvestia/2015/2015_3_115_127.pdf.
Нелаева, Галина А., Наталья В. Сидорова, Елена А. Хабарова. 2020. «Криминализация отрицания Холокоста и других международных преступлений: обзор европейской и российской практики». Международное правосудие 1 (33): 33–49. https://doi.org/10.21128/2226-2059-2020-1-33-49
Пресняков, Михаил В. 2019. «Проблемы содержательной определенности основных прав и свобод: конституционные идеалы и текущее законодательное регулирование». Вестник Поволжского института управления 19 (4): 29–40. https://doi.org/10.22394/1682-2358-2019-4-29-40
Рыжов, Игорь В., Мария Ю. Бородина. 2015. «Проблема отрицания Холокоста: история, особенности и современные тенденции». Вестник Нижегородского университета им. Н. И. Лобачевского 3: 97–102.
Шапиро, Пол. 2011. «“В России просто обязаны изучать Холокост”. Беседу ведет Станислав Будницкий». Лехаим 1 (225). Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://lechaim.ru/ARHIV/225/interview.htm.
Aretz, Emil. 1976. Hexen-Einmal-Eins Einer Luge. Pahl: Verlag Hohe Warte.
Belavusau, Uladzislau, Aleksandra Gliszczyńska-Grabias. 2017. Law and memory: Towards legal governance of history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Christophersen, Thies. 2007. Auschwitz: A personal account. London: Steven Books.
Duppelfeld, Monika. 2009. “Holocaust denial laws versus hate speech laws in general: How far can we stretch freedom of expression?” LLM Research Paper, Victoria University of Wellington.
Friedrich, Christof, Eric Thomson. 1980. The Hitler we loved & why. Reedy, White Power Publications.
Gliszczyńska-Grabias, Aleksandra. 2013. “Penalizing Holocaust denial: A view from Europe”. Global antisemitism: A crisis of modernity. Vol. 1: Conceptual approaches. Ed. by Charles A. Small, 237–256.Leiden: Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004265561_023
Graf, Jurgen, Thomas Kues, Carlo Mattogno. 2020. Sobibor: Holocaust propaganda and reality. Uckfield: Castle Hill Publ.
Gzoyan, Edita. 2016. “Genocide denial under constitutional law: Comparative analysis of Spain, Germany and France”. International Journal of Armenian Genocide Studies 3 (1): 72–87.
Harwood, Richard E. 1974. Did six million really die? The truth at last. Richmond, Surrey: Historical Review Press.
Hennebel, Ludovic, Thomas Hochmann. 2011. Genocide Denials and the Law. New York; Oxford; Oxford University Press. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. http://lib.ysu.am/disciplines_bk/384b4722956204a08c920c3c3e79af85.pdf.
Hoggan, David L. 1969. The myth of the six million. Los Angeles: The Noontide Press.
Irving, David John Cawdell. 2002. Hitler’s War. London: Focal Point.
Kahn, Robert A. 2004. Holocaust denial and the law: A comparative study. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781403980502
Kokh, Alfred, Pavel Polian, eds. 2012. Denial of the denial, or the battle of Auschwitz. The demography and geopolitics of the Holocaust: The view from the Twenty-First century. Boston: Academic Studies Press.
Koposov, Nikolay. 2018. Memory laws, memory wars: The politics of the past in Europe and Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lasson, Kenneth. 2007. “Defending truth: legal and psychological aspects of Holocaust denial”. Current Psychology (A Journal for Diverse Perspectives on Diverse Psychological Issues) 26: 223–266. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-007-9013-7
Lechtholz-Zey, Jacqueline. 2012. “The laws banning Holocaust denial — revised”. Genocide Prevention Now(GPN) 9. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://www.ihgjlm.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Laws_Banning_Holocaust_Denial.pdf.
Leuchter, Fred A., Robert Faurisson, Germar Rudolf. 2005. Leuchter reports: Critical edition. Chicago: Theses and Dissertations Press.
Mathis, Andrew E. 2006. “General semantics and Holocaust denial”. ETC: A Review of General Semantics 1 (63): 52–61. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20080513180534/ http://www.holocaust-history.org/gen-semantics/gs.pdf.
Rassinier, Paul. 1949. Passage de la ligne. Bourg-en-Bresse: Editions bressanes.
Rassinier, Paul. 1976. The drama of the European Jews. Silver Spring, Steppingstones Publ.
Rassinier, Paul. 1978a. Debunking the genocide myth: A Study of the Nazi concentration camps and the alleged extermination of European Jewry. Los Angeles: Noontide Press.
Rassinier, Paul. 1978b. The Holocaust story and the lies of Ulysses: A study of the German concentration camps and the alleged extermination of European Jewry. Costa Mesa, Institute for Historical Review.
Smith, Roger W. 2010. “Legislating against genocide denial: Criminalizing denial or preventing free speech?” University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy 4: 128–137. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://ir.stthomas.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1050&context=ustjlpp.
Turanjanin, Veljko. 2022. “Genocide denial and freedom of expression”. Scientific meeting “80 Years since the Pogrom in the Great Raid a Step Further toward the Common Future” Conference Papers, 203–228. Novi Sad, Покраjински заштитник граhana — омбудсман, Матица српска. Дата обращения 25 июня, 2023. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365236935_GENOCIDE_DENIAL_AND_FREEDOM_OF_EXPRESSION.
Vidal-Naquet, Pierre, Limor Yagil, 1995. Holocaust denial in France. A unique phenomenon. Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University.
Wistrich, Robert S., ed. 2017. Holocaust denial: The politics of perfidy. Jerusalem: The Hebrew University Magnes Press; Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter.
References
Al’tman, Il’ia A. 2022. History of the Holocaust and genocides. 20th century. Moscow, MIK Publ. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://holocf.ru/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Holokost_2022-02-13_out-1.pdf. (In Russian)
Aramyan, Aram Zh. 2016. “Some problems related to the application of Article 17 in the cases of Holocaust denial in the practice of the European Court of Human Rights”. Vestnik Rossiisko-Armianskogo (Slavianskogo)universiteta. Ser. Gumanitarnye i obshchestvennye nauki 1 (22): 14–20. (In Russian)
Aretz, Emil. 1976. Hexen-Einmal-Eins Einer Luge. Pahl, Verlag Hohe Warte.
Belavusau, Uladzislau, Aleksandra Gliszczyńska-Grabias. 2017. Law and memory: Towards legal governance of history. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Blagin, Anton. 2015. “Jews! Return the money to the Germans for fraud with ‘Holocaust six millions Jews’!”. LiveJournal. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://blagin-anton.livejournal.com/666403.html. (In Russian)
Christophersen, Thies. 2007. Auschwitz: A personal account. London, Steven Books.
Dodonov, Vyacheslav N. 2014. “Criminal-law protection of the historical truth: The international experience and the development of Russian legislation”. Vestnik Akademii General’noi prokuratury Rossiiskoi Federatsii 3 (41): 87–96. (In Russian)
Duppelfeld, Monika. 2009. “Holocaust denial laws versus hate speech laws in general: How far can we stretch freedom of expression?” LLM Research Paper, Victoria University of Wellington.
Friedrich, Christof, Eric Thomson. 1980. The Hitler we loved & why. Reedy, White Power Publications.
Gliszczyńska-Grabias, Aleksandra. 2013. “Penalizing Holocaust denial: A view from Europe”. Global antisemitism: A crisis of modernity. Vol. 1: Conceptual approaches. Ed. by Charles A. Small, 237–256.Leiden, Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004265561_023
Golovnenkov, Pavel V. 2021. Criminal statute (Criminal code) of the Federal Republic of Germany: Scientific and practical commentary and translation of the text of the law. Potsdam, Universitatsverlag Potsdam Publ. https://doi.org/10.25932/publishup-47371 (In Russian)
Graf, Jurgen, Thomas Kues, Carlo Mattogno. 2020. Sobibor: Holocaust propaganda and reality. Uckfield, Castle Hill Publ.
Gudkov, Lev D., Nataliya A. Zorkaya, Ekaterina V. Kochergina, Evgenia V. Lezina. 2016. “Anti-Semitism in the structure of Russia’s popular xenophobia: The negative identity and mobilizing potential”. Vestnik obshchestvennogo mneniia. Dannye. Analiz. Diskussii 1–2 (122): 140–197. (In Russian)
Gzoyan, Edita. 2016. “Genocide denial under constitutional law: Comparative analysis of Spain, Germany and France”. International Journal of Armenian Genocide Studies 3 (1): 72–87.
Harwood, Richard E. 1974. Did six million really die? The truth at last. Richmond, Surrey, Historical Review Press.
Hennebel, Ludovic, Thomas Hochmann. 2011. Genocide Denials and the Law. New York; Oxford, Oxford University Press. Accessed June 25, 2023. http://lib.ysu.am/disciplines_bk/384b4722956204a08c920c3c3e79af85.pdf.
Hoggan, David L. 1969. The myth of the six million. Los Angeles, The Noontide Press.
Irving, David John Cawdell. 2002. Hitler’s War. London, Focal Point.
Kahn, Robert A. 2004. Holocaust denial and the law: A comparative study. New York, Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781403980502
Koposov, Nikolay. 2018. Memory laws, memory wars: The politics of the past in Europe and Russia. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Lasson, Kenneth. 2007. “Defending truth: legal and psychological aspects of Holocaust denial”. Current Psychology (A Journal for Diverse Perspectives on Diverse Psychological Issues) 26: 223–266. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-007-9013-7
Lechtholz-Zey, Jacqueline. 2012. “The laws banning Holocaust denial — revised”. Genocide Prevention Now(GPN) 9. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://www.ihgjlm.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Laws_Banning_Holocaust_Denial.pdf.
Leuchter, Fred A., Robert Faurisson, Germar Rudolf. 2005. Leuchter reports: Critical edition. Chicago, Theses and Dissertations Press.
Mathis, Andrew E. 2006. “General semantics and Holocaust denial”. ETC: A Review of General Semantics 1 (63): 52–61. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20080513180534/ http://www.holocaust-history.org/gen-semantics/gs.pdf.
Nelaeva, Galina A., Natalia V. Sidorova, Elena A. Khabarova. 2020. “Criminalization of Holocaust denial and of other international crimes: A review of European and Russian praxis”. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie 1 (33): 33–49. https://doi.org/10.21128/2226-2059-2020-1-33-49 (In Russian)
Presnyakov, Mikhail V. 2019. “Problems of substantive certainty of fundamental rights and freedoms: Constitutional ideals and current legislative regulation”. Vestnik Povolzhskogo instituta upravleniia 19 (4): 29–40. https://doi.org/10.22394/1682-2358-2019-4-29-40 (In Russian)
Rassinier, Paul. 1949. Passage de la ligne. Bourg-en-Bresse, Editions bressanes.
Rassinier, Paul. 1976. The drama of the European Jews. Silver Spring, Steppingstones Publ.
Rassinier, Paul. 1978a. Debunking the genocide myth: A Study of the Nazi concentration camps and the alleged extermination of European Jewry. Los Angeles, Noontide Press.
Rassinier, Paul. 1978b. The Holocaust story and the lies of Ulysses: A study of the German concentration camps and the alleged extermination of European Jewry. Costa Mesa, Institute for Historical Review.
Ryzhov, Igor V., Mariya Yu. Borodina. 2015. “The problem of denying the Holocaust: History, peculiarities and contemporary trends”. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N. I. Lobachevskogo 3: 97–102. (In Russian)
Shapiro, Pol. 2011. “‘Russia is simply obliged to study the Holocaust’. Interview by Stanislav Budnitskii”. Lekhaim 1 (225). Accessed June 25, 2023. https://lechaim.ru/ARHIV/225/interview.htm. (In Russian)
Smith, Roger W. 2010. “Legislating against genocide denial: Criminalizing denial or preventing free speech?” University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy 4: 128–137. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://ir.stthomas.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1050&context=ustjlpp.
Turanjanin, Veljko. 2022. “Genocide denial and freedom of expression”. Scientific meeting “80 Years since the Pogrom in the Great Raid a Step Further toward the Common Future” Conference Papers, 203–228. Novi Sad, Pokrajinski zashtitnik grahana — ombudsman, Matitsa srpska. Accessed June 25, 2023. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365236935_GENOCIDE_DENIAL_AND_FREEDOM_OF_EXPRESSION.
Varchenko, Igor A., Larisa G. Litvyak. 2015. “Criminal legislation of foreign countries about responsibility for the crimes similar Art. 354.1 of the Criminal Code of Russian Federation ‘Rehabilitation of Nazism’(Part 2)”. Gumanitarnye, sotsial’no-ekonomicheskie i obshchestvennye nauki 11–1: 257–260. (In Russian)
Vavilova, Kristina A. 2015. “The development of revisionist thoughts in the Russian historiography of the Holocaust”. Vestnik Kemerovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 1–3 (61): 132–136. (In Russian)
Vetoshkina, Ekaterina D. 2020. “Holocaust denial: Social conditionality and comparative analysis of criminal law prohibition”. Lex Russica 11 (168): 129–138. https://doi.org/10.17803/1729-5920.2020.168.11.129-138 (In Russian)
Vidal-Naquet, Pierre, Limor Yagil, 1995. Holocaust denial in France. A unique phenomenon. Tel Aviv, Tel Aviv University.
Wistrich, Robert S., ed. 2017. Holocaust denial: The politics of perfidy. Jerusalem: The Hebrew University Magnes Press; Berlin and Boston, De Gruyter.
Zemskov, Viktor N. 2015. “Is the extent of the Soviet casualties in 1941–1945 still debatable?” Izvestiia Samarskogo nauchnogo tsentra Rossiiskoi akademii nauk 17 (3): 115–127. Accessed June 25, 2023. http://www.ssc.smr.ru/media/journals/izvestia/2015/2015_3_115_127.pdf. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
2023-09-28
How to Cite
Shulga, R. Y. (2023). Legal aspects of liability for Holocaust denial in Russia (through the prism of Roman Yushkov case). Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law, 14(3), 595–609. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2023.303
Issue
Section
Public and Private Law: Applied Research
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
