Cases relating to the law of the sea: Issues of jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice

Alexander Vylegzhanin; Olga I. Zinchenko

doi:10.21638/spbu14.2023.308

Authors

Alexander Vylegzhanin MGIMO University, 76, pr. Vernadskogo, Moscow, 119454, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4833-2525
Olga I. Zinchenko Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation, 32/34, Smolenskaya-Sennaya pl., Moscow, 119200, Russian Federation https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0864-249X

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2023.308

Abstract

The law of the sea (LOS) cases regularly appear on the International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) docket, allowing it to rule on important substantive aspects of this branch of international law. The article focuses on the way these cases have “carved” the Court’s approaches to jurisdictional issues throughout its history. Combining theoretic and practical considerations, the study explores and assesses each jurisdictional basis set forth in Art. 36 of the Statute of the ICJ through the lens of law of the sea disputes considered by the Court: special agreements, jurisdictional clauses of treaties and “Optional clause” declarations. The study also analyses the modern trends in the settlement of the law of the sea disputes in the ICJ, their root causes, the practical “strengths and weaknesses” of various jurisdictional tools for seizin the ICJ, as well as the consequences of some of its key judgments for the future of dispute resolution in the law of the sea. The article also challenges — from a purely legal standpoint — the relevant terms (jurisdiction, competence, reservations and conditions) used in academic sources, political discourse and even in official documents on the jurisdiction of the Court. Due to a variety of fora that may be chosen by States to refer the LOS disputes, the study offers a helpful recapitulation of how the Court’s general approaches to jurisdiction were applied in the specific context of the LOS cases, which may serve as a basis for further comparative studies of jurisdictional approaches of other bodies competent to deal with the LOS disputes, inter alia providing valuable information for decision-makers on the prospects of lodging a potential application.

Keywords:

law of the sea, jurisdiction, competence, optional clause, unilateral declaration, compromis, special agreement, compromissory clause, forum prorogatum

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

References

Abraham, Ronny. 2016. “Presentation of the International Court of Justice over the last ten years”. Journal of International Dispute Settlement 7: 297–307.

Akande, Dapo. 2016. “Selection of the International Court of Justice as a forum for contentious and advisory proceedings (including jurisdiction)”. Journal of International Dispute Settlement 7 (2): 320–344.

Alexandrov, Stanimir. A. 1995. Reservations in Unilateral Declarations Accepting the Compulsory Jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice. Leiden, Brill.

Bankes, Nigel. 2017. “The relationship between declarations under the optional clause of the statute of the International Court of Justice and Part XV of the Law of the Sea Convention”. The NCLOS Blog. Accessed January 12, 2022. https://site.uit.no/nclos/2017/02/10/the-relationship-between-declarationsunder-the-optional-clause-of-the-statute-of-the-international-court-of-justice-and-part-xv-of-thelaw-of-the-sea-convention.

Benatar, Marko, Erik Franckx. 2017. “The ICJ’s preliminary objections judgment in Somalia v. Kenya: Causing ripples in law of the sea dispute settlement?” EJIL: Talk! Blog. Accessed January 12, 2022. https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-icjs-preliminary-objections-judgment-in-somalia-v-kenya-causing-ripples-inlaw-of-the-sea-dispute-settlement.

Churchill, Robin. 2008. “Dispute settlement under the UN Convention on the law of the sea: Survey for 2007”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 23: 601–642.

Churchill, Robin. 2009. “Dispute settlement under the UN Convention on the law of the sea: Survey for 2008”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 24: 603–616.

Churchill, Robin. 2015. “Dispute settlement in the law of the sea: Survey for 2014”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 30: 585–653.

Churchill, Robin. 2017. “Dispute settlement in the law of the sea: Survey for 2015, Part II and 2016”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 32: 379–426.

Churchill, Robin. 2018. “Dispute settlement in the law of the sea: Survey for 2017”. International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 33: 653–682.

Churchill, Robin. 2020. “Dispute settlement in the law of the sea: Survey for 2019”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 35: 621–659.

Collier, John, Vaughan Lowe. 2000. The Settlement of Disputes in International Law. Institutions and Procedures. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Crawford, James. 2012. Brownlie’s Principles of Public International Law. 8th ed. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Elferink, Alex G. Oude, Tore Henriksen, Signe Veierud Busch. 2019. Maritime Boundary Delimitation: The Case Law. Is It Consistent and Predictable? Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Gautier, Philippe. 2014. “The settlement of disputes” The IMLI Manual on International Maritime Law. Ed. by David. P. Attard, 533–576. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Higgins, Rosalyn. 1995. Problems and Process: International Law and How We Use It. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Kwiatkowska, Barbara. 1999. “Fisheries jurisdiction (Spain v. Canada), jurisdiction”. The American Journal of International Law 93 (2): 502–507.

Kwiatkowska, Barbara. 2001. “The law of the sea related cases in the International Court of Justice during the presidency of judge Stephen M. Schwebel (1997–2000)”. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 16 (1): 1–40.

Mackenzie, Ruth, Cesare Romano, Yuval Shany, Philippe Sands. 2010. The Manual on International Courts and Tribunals. 2nd ed. New York, Oxford University Press.

Nandan, Satya, Shabtai Rosenne. 1993. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. A Commentary. In 7 vols, vol. 2. Leiden, Martinus Nijhoff Publ.

Owada, Hisashi. 2010. Introductory Remarks at the Seminar on the Contentious Jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice. Accessed December 4, 2021. https://www.icj-cij.org/public/files/pressreleases/5/16225.pdf.

Rosenne, Shabtai. 2007. “Arbitrations under Annex VII of the United Nations Convention on the law of the sea”. Law of the sea, environmental law and settlement of disputes: Liber amicorum judge Thomas A. Mensah. Ed. by Tafsir Malick Ndiaye, 989–1006. Leiden, Nĳhoff.

Shaw, Malcolm. 2017. International Law. 8th ed. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Thirlway, Hugh. 2016. The International Court of Justice. New York, Oxford University Press.

Tomuschat, Christian. 2019. “Article 36”. The Statute of the International Court of Justice: A Commentary. 3rd ed., eds Andreas Zimmermann, Christian Tams, Karin Oellers-Frahm, Christian. P. Tomuschat, 712–798. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Treves, Tullio. 2007. “Dispute-settlement in the law of the sea: Disorder or system?” Promoting Justice, Human Rights and Conflict Resolution through International Law / La promotion de la justice, des droits de l’homme et du règlement des conflits par le droit international. Ed. by Kohen, Marcelo, 927–949. Leiden, Brill Nijhoff.

Xue, Hanqin. 2017. Jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice. Leyden, Brill; Nijhoff.