On the question of the state succession legality
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2022.307Abstract
On December 10, 2019, the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation issued Decision № 39-P, and in his opinion, judge Aranovskii described the USSR as an “illegitimately established state” and called for Russia not to be considered the legal successor of the USSR. Thus, judge Aranovskii touched upon the sphere of State succession, the regulation of which is related to international law and not to constitutional law. In particular, Aranovskii raised such problems as the legality of succession. Relevant provisions on legality are also included in existing international treaties on the succession of states, such as the 1978 Vienna Convention on the succession of states in respect to treaties and the 1983 Vienna Convention on the succession of states in respect to state property, state archives, and public debts, as well as Articles on the nationality of natural persons in relation to the succession of states. The issue of the legality of state succession was also highlighted in the second report on the issue of state succession in respect of responsibility for internationally wrongful acts by the International Law Commission Special Rapporteur Pavel Šturma. Research on this issue is important because the provisions on Russia as the legal successor to the USSR were proposed as one of the amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation, which will be approved by the Russian people in an all-Russian vote. In order to make a legal assessment of the legality of state succession, it is important to analyse the history of the relevant provisions in existing international treaties, as well as to analyse the relevant international legal practice on this issue. This research will assess the reasonableness of both the opinion of judge Aranovskii and the corresponding amendment to the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
Keywords:
state succession, succession legality, the Russian Federation succession, succession in relation to responsibility, universal succession, obligations ex delicto, theory of material substitution, negative theory
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Библиография
Блюнчли, Иоганн К. 1877. Международное право цивилизованных государств, изложенное в виде кодекса. М.: Типография Индрих.
Ваттель, Эмер де. 1960. Право народов или принципы естественного права, применяемые к поведению и делам наций и суверенов. М.: Госюриздат.
Витцтум, Вольфганг Г., Михаэль Боте, Рудольф Дольцер, Марсель Кау, Эккарт Кляйн, Филип Куниг, Александер Прёльсс, Штефани Шмаль, Майнхард Шрёдер. 2015. Международное право. М.: Инфотропик Медиа.
Гревцов, Юрий И., Игорь Ю. Козлихин. 2008. Энциклопедия права. СПб.: Издательский дом Санкт-Петербургского университета.
Гроций, Гуго. 1994. О праве войны и мира. М.: Ладомир.
Мартенс, Федор Ф. 2008. Современное международное право цивилизованных народов. М.: Зерцало.
Новицкий, Иван Б. 2020. Римское право. М.: Юрайт.
Фердросс, Альфред. 1959. Международное право. М.: Иностранная литература.
Appleton, Henri. 1895. Des effets des annexions sur les dettes de l’Etat démembré ou annexé. Paris: L. Larose.
Bedjaoui, Mohammed. 1970. “Problèmes récents de succession d’Etats dans les Etats nouveaux”. Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law 130: 455–585.
Cahier, Philippe. 1984. “Quelques aspects de la Convention de 1978 sur la succession d’états en matière des traités”. Mélanges Georges Perrin: Recueil de travaux offerts à M. Georges Perrin, 63–76. Lausanne: Diffusion Payot.
Cavaglieri, Arrigo. 1929. “Règles générales du droit de la paix”. Collected Courses of The Hague Academy of International Law 26: 311–585.
Corten, Olivier. 2006. “Are there gaps in the international law of secession?” Secession: International Law Perspectives, 231–254. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Crawford, James. 2007. The creation of states in international law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Crawford, James. 2013. State responsibility. The general part. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Desparget, Frantz. 1910. Cours de Droit International Public. Paris: L. Larose et L. Tenin.
Distefano, Giovanni, Gloria Gaggioli, Aymeric Hêche, eds. 2016. La Convention de Vienne de 1978 sur la Succession d’États en matière de traités: Commentaire article par article et études thématiques. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Bruxelles: Bruylant.
Dumberry, Patrick. 2007. State Succession to International Responsibility. Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff Publ.
Fiore, Pasquale. 1911. Le droit international codifié et sa sanction juridique. Paris: A. Pedone.
Hall, William E. 1924. A treatise on international law. Oxford: The Clarendon Press.
Hallek, Henry W. 1893. International law. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London: K. Paul, Trench, Trübner & Co.
Keith, Arthur B. 1907. The theory of state succession with specific reference to English and colonial law. London: Waterlow and Sons.
Lauterpacht, Hersch. 1927. Private law sources and analogies of international law. London: Longmans, Green and Co.
Manning, William O. 1875. Commentaries on the law of nations. London: S. Sweet.
Marcoff, Marco G. 1969. Accession à l’indépendance et succession d’Etats aux traités internationaux. Fribourg: Editions Universitaires.
Merignhac, Alexandre. 1907. Traité de droit international public. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Paris: F. Pichon et Durand-Auzias.
Milanović, Marko, Michael Wood, eds. 2015. The law and politics of the Kosovo advisory opinion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Milanović, Marko. 2011. “What the Kosovo advisory opinion means for the rest of the world”. ASIL Proceedings 105: 259–275.
Monnier, Jean-Philippe. 1962. “La succession d’Etats en matière de responsabilité internationale”. Annuaire Français de Droit International 8: 65–90.
Nys, Ernest. 1904. Le droit international: Les principes, les théories, les faits. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Brussels: A. Castaigne.
O’Connell, Daniel P. 1956. The law of state succession. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Phillimore, Robert. 1871. Commentaries on international law. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London: Butterworth.
Pradier-Fodere, Paul. 1885. Traité de droit international public européen et américain. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Paris: A. Pedone.
Pufendorf, Samuel. 1734. Le Droit de la nature et des gens. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Amsterdam: Chez la veuve de Pierre de Coup.
Rivier, Alphonse. 1896. Principes du droit des gens. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Paris: A. Rousseau.
Stern, Brigitte. 1996. “La succession d’États”. Collected courses of The Hague Academy of International Law 262: 9–437.
Tancredi, Antonello. 2016. “In search of a fair balance between the inviolability of borders, self-determination and secession in international law”. Law, Territory and Conflict Resolution: Law as a Problem and Law as a Solution, 90–104. Leiden: Brill Nijhoff.
Westlake, John. 1904. International law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wheaton, Henry. 1866. Elements of international law. London: Stevens and Sons.
Woolsey, Theodore D. 1899. Introduction to the study of international law. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
References
Appleton, Henri. 1895. Des effets des annexions sur les dettes de l’Etat démembré ou annexé. Paris, L. Larose.
Bedjaoui, Mohammed. 1970. “Problèmes récents de succession d’Etats dans les Etats nouveaux”. Collected Courses of the Hague Academy of International Law 130: 455–585.
Bluntschli, Johann C. 1877. The modern international law of civilised nations presented as the code. Moscow, Tipografiia Indrikh Publ. (In Russian)
Cahier, Philippe. 1984. “Quelques aspects de la Convention de 1978 sur la succession d’états en matière des traités”. Mélanges Georges Perrin: Recueil de travaux offerts à M. Georges Perrin, 63–76. Lausanne: Diffusion Payot.
Cavaglieri, Arrigo. 1929. “Règles générales du droit de la paix”. Collected Courses of The Hague Academy of International Law 26: 311–585.
Corten, Olivier. 2006. “Are there gaps in the international law of secession?” Secession: International Law Perspectives, 231–254. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Crawford, James. 2007. The creation of states in international law. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Crawford, James. 2013. State responsibility. The general part. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Desparget, Frantz. 1910. Cours de Droit International Public. Paris, L. Larose et L. Tenin.
Distefano, Giovanni, Gloria Gaggioli, Aymeric Hêche, eds. 2016. La Convention de Vienne de 1978 sur la Succession d’États en matière de traités: Commentaire article par article et études thématiques. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Bruxelles, Bruylant.
Dumberry, Patrick. 2007. State Succession to International Responsibility. Leiden, Martinus Nijhoff Publ.
Fiore, Pasquale. 1911. Le droit international codifié et sa sanction juridique. Paris, A. Pedone.
Grevtsov, Iurii I., Igor’ Iu. Kozlikhin. 2008. Encyclopedia of Law. St Petersburg, St Petersburg University Press. (In Russian)
Grotius, Hugo. 1994. On the law of war and peace. Rus. ed. Moscow, Ladomir Publ. (In Russian)
Hall, William E. 1924. A treatise on international law. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.
Hallek, Henry W. 1893. International law. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London, K. Paul, Trench, Trübner & Co.
Keith, Arthur B. 1907. The theory of state succession with specific reference to English and colonial law. London, Waterlow and Sons.
Lauterpacht, Hersch. 1927. Private law sources and analogies of international law. London, Longmans, Green and Co.
Manning, William O. 1875. Commentaries on the law of nations. London, S. Sweet.
Marcoff, Marco G. 1969. Accession à l’indépendance et succession d’Etats aux traités internationaux. Fribourg, Editions Universitaires.
Merignhac, Alexandre. 1907. Traité de droit international public. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Paris, F. Pichon et Durand-Auzias.
Milanović, Marko, Michael Wood, eds. 2015. The law and politics of the Kosovo advisory opinion. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Milanović, Marko. 2011. “What the Kosovo advisory opinion means for the rest of the world”. ASIL Proceedings 105: 259–275.
Monnier, Jean-Philippe. 1962. “La succession d’Etats en matière de responsabilité internationale”. Annuaire Français de Droit International 8: 65–90.
Novitskii, Ivan B. 2020. Roman law. Moscow, Iurait Publ. (In Russian)
Nys, Ernest. 1904. Le droit international: Les principes, les théories, les faits. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Brussels, A. Castaigne.
O’Connell, Daniel P. 1956. The law of state succession. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Phillimore, Robert. 1871. Commentaries on international law. In 2 vols, vol. 1. London, Butterworth.
Pradier-Fodere, Paul. 1885. Traité de droit international public européen et américain. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Paris, A. Pedone.
Pufendorf, Samuel. 1734. Le Droit de la nature et des gens. In 2 vols, vol. 2. Amsterdam, Chez la veuve de Pierre de Coup.
Rivier, Alphonse. 1896. Principes du droit des gens. In 2 vols, vol. 1. Paris, A. Rousseau.
Stern, Brigitte. 1996. “La succession d’États”. Collected courses of The Hague Academy of International Law 262: 9–437.
Tancredi, Antonello. 2016. “In search of a fair balance between the inviolability of borders, self-determination and secession in international law”. Law, Territory and Conflict Resolution: Law as a Problem and Law as a Solution, 90–104. Leiden, Brill Nijhoff.
Vattel, Emer de. 1960. The law of nations: or, Principles of the law of nature applied to the conduct and affairs of nations and sovereigns. Rus. ed. Moscow, Gosiurizdat Publ. (In Russian)
Verdross, Alfred. 1959. Völkerrecht. Rus. ed. Moscow, Inostrannaia literatura Publ. (In Russian)
Vitzthum, Wolfgang G., Michael Bothe, Rudolf Dolzer, Marcel Kau, Eckart Klein, Philip Kunig, Alexander Proelß, Stefanie Schmahl, Meinhard Schröder. 2015. Völkerrecht. Rus. ed. Moscow, Infotropik Media Publ. (In Russian)
Westlake, John. 1904. International law. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Wheaton, Henry. 1866. Elements of international law. London, Stevens and Sons.
Woolsey, Theodore D. 1899. Introduction to the study of international law. New York, Charles Scribner’s Sons.
Downloads
Published
2022-09-22
How to Cite
Garkusha-Bozhko, S. Y. (2022). On the question of the state succession legality. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law, 13(3), 696–711. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu14.2022.307
Issue
Section
Foreign and International Law
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Law" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
